Home ➞ Iconology ➞ Interpretations Iconology of the Wayfarer Triptych Table View Explore by: # Keywords⚆ Visual Attributes Iconology - Filter Painting An Allegory of Intemperance Death and the Miser Ship of Fools The Pedlar Visual Objects Carried out by Category Aspects of time Bible and biblical stories Christianity and the Church Earth and world Human being and life Intention, will and state of being Literary and mythical characters and objects Morality and immorality Non-Christian religions Planets and zodiacal signs Reasoning, judgement and intelligence Scientific perspectives and methods Social conduct and emotions Social life, culture and activities Society and social classes Supernaturalism and magic Keywords Death Refers to "Carrus Navalis in Schönbartbuch", 16th century "Carrus Navalis in Schönbartbuch", 1908 "Death, from Grandes heures de Rohan", ca. 1401-1500 "Deathbed, from The Hours of Catherine of Cleves", ca. 1440 "de l’ouïe et du goût", ca. 1510-1520 "Detail, infrared reflectogram image of Death and the Miser", 1982 "Flight into Egypt", ca. 1500 "La barque d’Ëve", ca. 1510-1520 "May, from Hours of Joanna I of Castile", ca. 1486-1506 "Pedlar, from The Luttrell Psalter", ca. 1325-1340 "Psalter of Eleanor of Aquitaine", ca. 1185 "Reconstruction of Ship of Fools after Seymour", 1984 "Saturn, from Astrological treatises", 15th century "Saturn and his children, from Passauer Calendar", 1445 "Terra, from Engelberg Crucifix", ca. 1200 "The Tree of Life", 1502 Abraham, Levy & Cantera, 1939 Adhémar, 1962 Aertsen, 1556 Aesop, ca. 1501 Agrippa, 1910 Ainsworth, 2010 Ainsworth et al., 2012 Alexandre, 1892 Allberry, 1938 Allegory of Chasity at the Bardi Chapel, ca. 1325 Altdorfer, ca. 1515-1516 Anthonisz, 1541 Antoninus, 1449 Antwerper Liedboek, 1544 Ariès, 1981 Ars moriendi, ca. 1415-1450 Ars moriendi, ca. 1474 Atkins, 2017 Augustodunensis, ca. 1080-1156 Avé-Lallemant, 1858 Badius, 1498 Badius, 1498 (Frontispiece) Badius, 1500 Badius, 1502 Baldass, 1926 Baldass, 1938 Baldass, 1943 Baldass, 1959 Baldass, 1968 Baldini, ca. 1464 Baltrusaitis, 1955 Barbado, 1931 Bass & Wyckoff, 2015 Bauer, 1989 Bax, 1948 Bax, 1949 Bax, 1953 Bax, 1962 Bax, 1979 Bayley, 1919 Bayot, 1929 Beagle, 1982 Bedaux & Ekkart, 2000 Beer, 1957 Beets, 1938 Beets, 1946 Beets, 1954 Beham, 1535 Beham, ca. 1530-1562 Bellaert, 1486 Benesch, 1937 Benesch, 1957 Bening, 1500 Bening, ca. 1515 Bening, ca. 1530 Bergmans, 1936 Bevers, 1986 Bidez & Cumont, 1938 Biesheuvel, 2005 Bigwood, 1921 Binski, 1996 Bishop, 1918 Bisschop & Verwijs, 1870 Bloch, 1912 Bloemaert, After 1635 Bloomfield, 1952 Boczkowska, 1971 Bohnert, 1985 Boll & Bezold, 1931 Boll, 1913 Bolswert, ca. 1610-1620 Bonenfant, 1958 Boon, 1968 Bosch, 15th century Bosch, 16th century Bosch, ca. 1475 Bosch, ca. 1475-1500 Bosch, ca. 1485 Bosch, ca. 1485-1490 Bosch, ca. 1490-1495 Bosch, ca. 1490-1500 Bosch, ca. 1494 (Ecce Homo) Bosch, ca. 1494 (Triptych of Adoration of the Magi) Bosch, ca. 1495–1500 Bosch, ca. 1498 Bosch, ca. 1500 Bosch, ca. 1500 (Johannes auf Patmos) Bosch, ca. 1500 (Temptations of St. Anthony) Bosch, ca. 1500 (The Pedlar) Bosch, ca. 1501-1505 Bosch, ca. 1504-1508 Bosch, ca. 1505 Bosch, ca. 1505-1510 Bosch, ca. 1510 Bosch, ca. 1512-1515 Bosch, ca. 1520-1545 Boschère, 1947 Bosing, 1987 Brabant, ca. 1460 Brands, 1921 Brans, 1948 Brant, 1494 Brant, 1498 Brant, 1498 (Frontispiece) Brant, 1500 Brant, 1854 Brant, 1944 Brant, 1962 Brant, 2011 Briffault, 1927 Brion, 1938 Brody, 1974 Bruegel, 1559 (Die niederländischen Sprichwörter) Bruegel, 1559 (Misanthropist) Bruegel, 1559 (The Fight between Carnival and Lent) Bruegel, 1562 Bruegel, 1564 Bruegel, 1565 Bruegel, 1565 (Der Frühling) Bruegel, 1567 Bruegel, 1568 Bruegel, 1568 (Les Mendiants ou Les Culs-de-jatte) Bruegel, 1568 (The Blind Leading the Blind) Bruegel, 1568 (The Magpie on the Gallows) Bruegel, 1574 Bruegel, ca. 1600-1624 Brummel, 1949 Bunyan, 1678 Burlington Fine Arts Club, 1908 Buytewech, ca. 1591-1624 Bücken & Steyaert, 2013 Calkins, 1978 Carefree living, ca. 1560 Cartellieri, 1929 Cats, 1642 Chailley, 1978 Chew, 1962 Ciceron, 1938 Cinotti, 1966 Cirlot, 1962 Cluse, 2000 Cohen, 1909 (Die Ausstellung des Goldenen Vlieses in Bru_gge, 1907) Cohen, 1909 (Hieronymus Bosch) Colenbrander, 2003 Combe, 1946 Combe, 1957 Comestor, ca. 1440 Condivi, 1927 Conway, 1921 Cooper, 1982 Crul, 1920 Cumont, 1942 Cuttler, 1957 Cuttler, 1968 Cuttler, 1969 D'Overflacque_e, 1932 Damascenus, 1879 Dante, ca. 1308-1321 Das Schiff der Flust, ca. 1360 da Vinci, ca. 1591-1624 de Beer, 1990 de Boschère, 1947 de Bruyn, 1601 de Bruyn, 1604 de Bruyn, 2001 de Bruyn, 2001 (Hieronymous Bosch's So-Called Prodigal Son Tondo) de Bruyn, 2017 de Cock, 1905 de Coster, 1867 de Diguleville, 1922 de Diguleville, ca. 1330-1331 (Pèlerinage de la vie humaine) de Diguleville, ca. 1330-1331 (Ship of Religion) de Haas, 1942 de Jode, 1590s de Jongh, 2000 de Julleville, 1889 de Laborde, 1929 Delaissé, 1959 Delevoy, 1960 Delevoy, 1990 de Mirimonde, 1971 Demonts, 1919 Demonts, 1920 de Mooij, 1992 de Mély, 1904 Der Melancholiker, 15th century de Roover, 1948 de Roover, 1967 Der verlorene Sohn beim Spiel im Freudenhaus, ca. 1520 de Tervarent, 1945 de Tervarent, 1958 de Tollenaere, 1941 de Tolnay, 1935 de Tolnay, 1937 de Tolnay, 1965 de Tolnay, 1966 Detroit Institute Arts, 1960 Devoghelaere, 1937 De Vos, 1967 Die vier Temperamente, ca. 1481 Dixon, 2003 Dolan, 1964 Donatello, ca. 1457-1464 Drescher, 1908 du Hameel, ca. 1478-1506 Dülberg, 1929 Dürer, 1494 (Frontispiece of Daß Narrenschyff ad Narragoniam) Dürer, 1494 (Of Serenading at Night) Dürer, 1514 Eisler, 1946 Eisler, 1946 (Zodiacal trines) Eisler, 1961 Eisler, 1977 Eliade, 1959 Elst, 1944 Elst, 1946 Encyclopaedia Judaica, 1971 Engler, 1962 English Standard Version Bible, 2001 Enklaar, 1922 Enklaar, 1933 Enklaar, 1937 Enklaar, 1940 Enklaar, 1956 Erasmus, 1828 Erasmus, 1913 Essling & Müntz, 1902 Fabre-Vassas, 1997 Falkenburg, 1988 Faris, 1914 Fierens, 1936 Fierens, 1947 Fischart, 1969 Fischer, 2016 Follower of Dreux Jean, ca. 1468-1477 Follower of Jheronimus Bosch, 15th century Follower of Jheronimus Bosch, ca. 1485-1490 Follower of Jheronimus Bosch, ca. 1555-1575 Follower of Jheronimus Bosch, ca. 1560 Follower of Jheronimus Bosch, ca. 1561 Follower of Pieter Bruegel, ca. 1550-1575 Follower of Pieter Huys, ca. 1560 Fourcaud, 1912 Fraenger, 1930 Fraenger, 1950 Fraenger, 1951 Fraenger, 1975 Fraenger, 1999 Francis, 1942 Frankfurter, 1952 Frey, 1957 Friedländer, 1927 Friedländer, 1935 Friedländer, 1969 Galle, ca. 1565 Ganz, 1924 Gaspar, 1932 Gerlach, 1939 Gerlach, 1978 Gerlach, 1979 Gibson, 1973 Gibson, 1973 (Hieronymus Bosch and the Dutch tradition) Gibson, 1973 (Hieronymus Bosch and the Mirror of Man) Gibson, 1983 Glück, 1904 Glück, 1933 Gossaert, 1919 Gossaert, ca. 1513-1515 Gossart, 1907 Gotthelf, 1948 Grimm, 1911 Gringore, 1512 Grossmann, 1955 Gundel, 1922 Gutekunst, 1899 Gérard, 1486-1487 Habig, 1973 Hals, ca. 1616-1617 Hammerstein, 1962 Hampe, 1902 Hand & Wolff, 1986 Hand, 1965 Hannema, 1931 Hannema, 1936 Hansen, 1984 Harms, 1970 Harrebomée, 1858 Harrebomée, 1861 Harrebomée, 1870 Harris, 1995 Hartau, 2001 Hartau, 2001 (Suche nach Glück bei nahem Untergang) Hartau, 2002 Hartau, 2005 Hartau, 2005 (Bosch and the Jews) Hartmann, 1493 Hauber, 1916 Heidrich, 1910 Heimann, 1990 Heitz, 1906 Hellerstedt, 1986 Hentze, 1932 Heremans, 1877 Hermans, 1867 Hildebrand, 1911 Hildegarde, 1903 Hilka, Schumann & Meyer, 1970 Hind, 1970 Holbein, ca. 1523 - 1525 Hollstein, 1949 Hooffacker, 1988 Horenbout, Bening & Bening, ca. 1510 (Mai) Horenbout, Bening & Bening, ca. 1515–1520 Huebner, 1943 Huebner, 1971 Huizinga, 1919 Hummelen, 1958 Huvenne, 1979 Ilsink, 2013 Ilsink, 2016 Ilsink et al., 2016 Ivanov, 1976 Janson, 1952 Jean de La Fontaine's philosophy, 17th century Jeltes, 1927 Jonas, 1958 Jonas, 1963 Justi, 1908 Kalff, 1884 Kalff, 1907 Kalff, 1923 Kasten, 1992 Kaye, 1998 Kempis, 1505 Klibansky, Panofsky & Saxl, 1964 Kohlhaussen, 1968 Koldeweij, Kooij & Vermet, 2001 Koldeweij, Vandenbroeck & Vermet, 2001 Konneker, 1966 Koomen, 1932 Koreny, 1986 Kozàky, 1944 Kren, McKendrick & Ainsworth, 2003 Kruyskamp, 1940 Labonnardiere, 1957 Laborde, 1923 Lacombe, 1963 Laenen, 1904 Lafond, 1914 Lammertse & van der Coelen, 2015 Lammertse, 1994 Lammertse, 2017 Langendijk, 1715 Laurent, ca. 1290-1300 (Gluttony) Laurent, ca. 1295 (Avarice) Leeber, 1939-1940 Leendertz Jr., 1907 Leendertz Jr., 1925 Leeu, 1492 Lefebvre, 1968 Le Goff, 1979 Lehrs, 1906 Leidinger, 1935 Le Juif errant: un témoin du temps, 2001 Lennep & Gouw, 1868 Le Tavernier & Miélot, ca. 1456 Le Tavernier & Miélot, ca. 1470 Leuvense Bijdragen IV, 1900-1902 Leuvense Bijdragen IX, 1910-1911 Levelt, 1924 Leymarie, 1949 Lindener, 1558 Lindner, 1912 Linfert, 1989 Lippmann, 1895 Liébault, 1582 Lottin, 1950 Lugt, 1968 Lurker, 1960 Lyna & van Eeghem, 1932 Långfors, 1921 Långfors, 1924 Maeterlinck, 1907 Mannhardt, 1858 Marijnissen, 1972 Marijnissen, 1976 Marijnissen, 1977 Marijnissen, 1987 Marijnissen, 2007 Maroto, 2001 Maroto, 2017 Marrow, 1977 Martindale & Bacchesch, 1969 Massys, 16th century Massys, ca. 1520-1525 Master of the Housebook, ca. 1475 Master of the Virgin among Virgins, ca. 1490 Mâle, 1908 Meadow, 1992 Meijer, 1946 Meiss, 1974 (French painting in the time of Jean de Berry) Meiss, 1974 (The Limbourgs and their contemporaries) Mellinkoff, 1993 Meurgey, 1930 Meyling, 1946 Michelangelo, 1533 Millar, 1953 Misero I, ca. 1465 Mollat, 1966 Monogrammist, ca. 1530 Morganstern, 1982 Morganstern, 1984 Moser, 1431 Moser, 1961 Mosmans, 1931 Mosmans, 1947 Moxey, 1985 Moxey, 1989 Müller, 1934 Nahuys, 1888 Nelson, 1969 Neumann, 1950 Neurdenburg, 1910 Nevitt, 2003 Newhauser, 1986 Nichols, 1992 Nielsen, 1904 Noonan, 1957 O'Brien-Moore, 1924 O'Connor, 1942 Offner & Steinweg, 1979 Olds, 1966 Oosterman, 2001 Orenstein, 2001 Owst, 1953 Panofsky & Saxl, 1933 Panofsky, 1939 Panofsky, 1953 Panofsky, Giehlow & Saxl, 1923 Parker, 2020 Parshall, 2001 Petrarch, 1532 Pfister, 1922 Philip, 1953 Philip, 1955 Philip, 1956 Philip, 1958 Philip, 1969 Pigler, 1950 Pleij, 1979 Pleij, 1983 Postan, 1963 Pourbus, c. 1547 Provoost, ca. 1515-1521 Puyvelde, 1956 Pächt, 1948 Pächt, 1950 Quarles, 1638 Quinot, 1962 Rabutaux, 1881 Rembert, 2004 Rembrandt, 1635 Renesse, 1900 Renger, 1969 Renger, 1970 Renger, 1976 Renouard, 1964 Reuterswärd, 1970 Rietstap, 1861 Ritter, Plessner & Mayriti, 1962 Romein & Romein, 1938 Roscher, 1878 Rosenberg, 1961 Rossiter, 1973 Rost, 16th century Rowlands, 1979 Ryckaert, ca. 1649 Saintyves, 1937 Sanger, 1897 Santurn (Lehrs), 15th century Sassen, 1885 Saturn (in Rome manuscript), 16th century Saturn (in Salone di Padua), 12th century Saturn (in Schermermar manuscript), 15th century Saturn and his 'Children' (Panofsky), 15th century Scaha gustationis sultae, 1500 Scháufelein, ca. 1525 Schedel, 1493 Schmitt, 1948 Schoemaker, ca. 1710-1735 Schönsperger, 1922 Schreiber & Zimmermann, 1937 Schreiber, 1926 Schretlen, 1925 Schürmeyer, 1923 Schwartz, 1997 Schwarz & Plagemann, 1937 Seligmann, 1953 Seymour, 1961 Shachar, 1974 Shestack, 1967 Silver, 1977 Silver, 1983 Silver, 1984 Silver, 1996 Silver, 2001 Silver, 2006 Silver, 2006 (Peasant scenes and landscapes) Silver, 2017 Sloet, 1890 Smeyers & Van der Stock, 1996 Smits, 1933 Snellaert, 1488 Solier, 1961 Speculum humanae salvationis, ca. 1466-1467 Spronk, 1998 Steen, ca. 1670 Stein-Schneider, 1984 Stoett, 1932 Stone-Ferrier, 1983 Strauss, 1926 Strauss, 1974 Stridbeck, 1956 Stürzinger, 1893 Suchier & Birch-Hirschfeld, 1913 Sudeck, 1931 Swain, 1932 Swelinck, 1627 Tallqvist, 1948 Tenenti, 1952 Tentler, 2003 Tentler, 2005 Terence, 2nd century BC The eating of the passover lamb, from Historia Scholastica, ca. 1450-1455 Thiele, 1898 Tinbergen, 1907 Titian, 1518 Tóth-Ubbens, 1987 Tuttle, 1981 Tuve, 1966 Universitätsbibliothek Basel & Universitätsbibliothek Freiburg im Breisgau, 1994 Valentiner & Suida, 1949 Valerius, 1942 van Andel, 1928 van Bastelaer, 1908 van Camp, 2017 van den Bossche, 1944 Vandenbroeck, 1981 Vandenbroeck, 1985 Vandenbroeck, 1987 Vandenbroeck, 1987 (Beeld van de andere, vertoog over het zelf) Vandenbroeck, 1989 Vandenbroeck, 2001 Vandenbroeck, 2002 Vandenbroeck, 2017 van der Heyden, 1559 van der Heyden, 1562 van der Heyden, 1562 (Marskramer door apen beroofd) van der Heyden, 1567 van der Heyden, 1570 van der Heyden, ca. 1551-1570 van der Heyden, ca. 1558 van de Venne, ca. 1625 Vandeweghe, 2017 van Dis & Erné, 1939 van Duyse, 1908 van Eyck, 1434 van Hemessen, 1536 van Hemessen, 1543 van Hemessen, ca. 1540 van Leyden, 1520 van Leyden, ca. 1520-1530 van Luttervelt, 1958 van Mander, 1604 van Meckenem, 15th century van Oestvoren, 1413 van Oostsanen, 1517 van Os, 1488 van Tricht, ca. 1492 van Wavere, ca. 1515 Venturi, 1945 Vermeylen, 1939 Verwijs & Verdam, 1885-1929 Verwijs, 1860 Verwijs, 1871 Vetter, 1955 Veurman & Bax, 1944 Vinken & Schlüter, 2000 Vinken, 1958 Visscher, 1614 von der Vogelweide, ca. 12-13th century von Eschenbach, ca. 1200-1210 von Fallersleben, 1855 von Fallersleben, 1968 von Kaysersberg, 1510 von Kaysersberg, 1511 von Seidlitz, 1935 Vostre, 1502 Wagner, 1845 Walker, 1975 Welsford, 1935 Werner, 1960 Wertheim Aymès, 1957 Wescher, 1946 Wieck, 1988 Wierix, ca. 1568 Wierix, ca. 1604 Wilhelm, 1990 Willshire, 1883 Winkel, 1922 Winkler, 1924 Winkler, 1951 Winternitz, 1967 Woordenboek der Nederlandsche Taal II, 1882 Woordenboek der Nederlandsche Taal III, 1912 Woordenboek der Nederlandsche Taal IV, 1916 Workshop of Orcagna, 15th-16th century Workshop of Taddeo Gaddi, 14th century Yamey, 1989 Zupnick, 1968 Refers To (Title) Contains symbolic references TextualVisual Types of Interpretation Conception of Information According to Furner (2004) Utterances Situations Thoughts Informativeness Relevance (Iconographical) Relevance (Iconological) Communication Layers of meaning According to van Straten (1994) Views of reality According to Popper (1972, 1979) & Gnoli (2018) Levels of knowledgeAccording to Nanetti (2018) If you are human, leave this field blank. This form is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Filter Entries Show All Δ 65 interpretations found. #53 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser The Washington panel, whose theme is the deadly sin of avarice, has been related to the popular Ars moriendi, or the Art of Dying Well [Ars moriendi, ca. 1415-1450], which was illustrated in woodcuts and engravings. Tervarent [de Tervarent, 1945, 61ff.], however, preferred to see its source in a death scene in a German miniature of the second quarter of the fifteenth century, in which he found a greater number of motifs related to the painting than can be discovered in Ars moriendi scenes. Bax [Bax, 1948, 244], however, cited a death scene from the Miracles de Nostre Dame in which a figure looks into a chest placed at the foot of the dying man’s bed; this he thought even more closely related to Bosch’s painting than the miniature cited by Tervarent. However, in these two scenes the chest is not that of a miser, which it certainly is in Bosch’s panel. (p.275) Cuttler, 1969 Bosch and the Narrenschiff: a problem in relationships #54 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser The association of the miser with a chest is an old one, and can be found illustrated in a number of late thirteenth and early fourteenth-century manuscripts of La Somme le Roi [Laurent, ca.1290-1300 (Avarice); Millar, 1953]. Bosch must have been well aware of this tradition, for demons aid the miser in his hoarding in the illuminations and in the Washington panel. (p.275) Cuttler, 1969 Bosch and the Narrenschiff: a problem in relationships #55 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser The illustration to Chapter XVII of Brant’s work, entitled Of Useless Riches, seems to be related compositionally to the Washington panel, and the final lines of the accompanying text present the moral… [Brant, 1944, 101] This chapter, significantly, follows one which castigates drunkenness and feasting, whose sinful overindulgence Bosch also warned against in the Louvre and Yale panels. Bosch, one may conclude, drew upon his memory of the Narrenschiff when he sketched out the composition of the Washington panel. Bosch’s miser is in keeping with the tradition of La Somme le Roi illustration, but is more subtly expressed than the obvious fool’s capped figure from the Narrenschiff. (p.275) Cuttler, 1969 Bosch and the Narrenschiff: a problem in relationships #59 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser …in this world greed and falsity go hand in hand in evil union. This allegorical statement was even stronger as Bosch first conceive it. The underdrawing, revealed by infrared photography [”Detail, infrared reflectogram image of Death and the Miser”, 1982], shows that the dying man in bed holds the viaticum in his hand, but in the final rendition the greedy sinner is still more interested in the moneybag offered by the demon than in the salvation the angel vainly tries to make him see might be his. Bosch had thus originally indicated that the avaricious would sell even the viaticum. (p.275-276) Cuttler, 1969 Bosch and the Narrenschiff: a problem in relationships #60 Knightly jousting objects, draped cloth with winged figure from Death and the Miser Viewed in this light, the association of the appurtenances of knighthood with the main theme of Avarice becomes understandable. This is not a social satire of the nobility, as Tolnay [de Tolnay, 1965, 25] thought, but a satire on the greed of false knights; it is also a statement of Bosch’s inherent pessimism. That all life leads to death is a truism, he seems to say, but men’s actions, because of the enormity of their sins, lead to an everlasting death without hope of resurrection to a new and better life. The baleful little man on the far side of the cloth hung over the low wall (a visual anticipation of the mounted skull-topped armored figure trailing a long cloth in the Lisbon panel) is a pictorial exposition of Bosch’s meaning, for in his thinking all the things of this world are permeated with evil. (p.276) Cuttler, 1969 Bosch and the Narrenschiff: a problem in relationships #93 Pennant with cresent symbol from Ship of Fools …the moon which appears as the attribute of the tree of life in The Ship of Fools is a symbol of the curriculum vitae. It signifies the material sublunar existence of man, subject to the laws of nature and the drift towards death. The moon was, indeed, used as a symbol of death in secular European art at various other periods apart from the Middle Ages [Cumont, 1942, 182ff.; Kozàky, 171; Eliade, 1959, 155]. (p.61) Boczkowska, 1971 The Lunar Symbolism of The Ship of Fools by Hieronymus Bosch #101 Jester from Ship of Fools The jester-fool was the type of the sinner who was subject not to the direction of the spirit but to sublunar matter, which the moon dispensed with its characteristic inconstancy [Swain, 1932, passim]… The moon is always interpreted as meaning human nature and the sun, the source of light, signifies God [Erasmus, 1828]. Thus in medieval literature the basic characteristics of stupidity were recognized as being derived from the inconstancy of the moon. Bosch has represented them in his lunar boat full of phlegmatics by the figure of a jester… The fool’s boat, in which the dominating figure of the jester symbolizes the folly derived from the moon as the source of sin and death. (pp.65-66) Boczkowska, 1971 The Lunar Symbolism of The Ship of Fools by Hieronymus Bosch #102 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser This image scholars have long associated with the Ars moriendi tradition, the Art of Dying Well, known from both didactic texts as well as engravings (Master E.S.) and woodcuts [Marijnissen, 1987; Ars moriendi, ca. 1415-1450; Schreiber & Zimmermann, 1937, 1121-1127; Binski, 1996, 39-43]. Bosch follows this tradition in showing the dying man on his deathbed receiving the last rites, the sacrament of unction. Paired on his headboard but unseen by him or by any of the visitors and officiants at his bedside, both an angel and a demon will wrestle for his soul, along with the skeletal figure of Death at the door, arrow in hand and pointed at the dying man. This is the same scenario that Bosch (in a painting equally marked by pentimenti but painted with the utmost skill, in contrast to the Prado deathbed) produced in a wing panel, Death of the Usurer. [O’Connor, 1942; Hand & Wolff, 1986, 16-22]. (p.629) Silver, 2001 God in the Details: Bosch and Judgment(s) #123 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser The usurer lies on his bed in a vacillating attitude, caught between Christian thoughts of redemption and a tenacious attraction to worldly pleasures. With one hand he reaches for a moneybag held by a toad-like monster, with the other he is pointing in the direction of death (originally this hand held a goblet; perhaps he wants to bargain with death). This indecisive vacillation was the general lot of Christians, as addressed, for instance, by St. Augustine [Labonnardiere, 1957, 137ff.; Quinot, 1962, 129ff.; Gérard, 1486-1487; Bax, 1979, pp. 320-324, note 10]. (pp. 39-40) Hartau, 2005 (Bosch and the Jews) Bosch and the Jews #230 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser It is the old and familiar scene of the Ars moriendi [Ars moriendi, ca. 1415-1450]. Death peers in at the door and aims with an arrow at the heart of the patient. Demons menace him and his guardian angel stands by him. In the foreground we see the absorbing passion of his life: the hoarding of riches to the delight of the evil spirits… The hour of death might be an illustration of these words. The preliminary drawing is apparent throughout the whole picture. A ray of sun pierces the glass pane with the crucifix, to which the angel directs the attention of the dying man. Evil demons creep out from below the ancestral furniture and the heraldic timber like rats to present at the deathbed the reckoning in the form of a thick bag of gold. (p. 33) Benesch, 1957 Hieronymus Bosch and the thinking of the late Middle Ages. #247 Boat with ten people onboard from Ship of Fools Die Verknu_pfung Wasser-Boot-Baum unter dem Gedanken Fahrt in den Tod findet sich bei Boschs Narrenschiff… (p. 32) Lurker, 1960 Der Baum in Glauben und Kunst: unter besonderer Berücksichtigung der Werke des Hieronymus Bosch #289 Ragged poor man from The Pedlar When read from left to right they show a chronological progression from life in this world to death and the hereafter (p. 191) Fischer, 2016 Jheronimus Bosch #291 Ragged poor man from The Pedlar The older and wiser pedlar, representing the viewer, takes the role of the penitent individual facing the end of his life (p. 191) Fischer, 2016 Jheronimus Bosch #307 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser The New Testament parable of the Rich Man and Lazarus the beggar [English Standard Version Bible, 2001, Luke, 15:19-31] offers only an indirect biblical source for Bosch’s painting, whose iconography is more closely related to late Medieval prints of the Ars moriendi, the arr of dying [Ars moriendi, ca. 1415-1450]. Such works advised those who wished to get to Heaven of the right way to prepare for death [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510]. Bosch shows an old miser, in his bedchamber and on the point of death, being exposed to temptation one decisive last time by a monster devil who offers him a bag of money. (p. 192) Fischer, 2016 Jheronimus Bosch #308 Figure with arrow behind door from Death and the Miser The drama of the scene is heightened by the arrival of Death, who is already standing in the open doorway. (p. 192) Fischer, 2016 Jheronimus Bosch #309 Winged figure behind man of his deathbed from Death and the Miser An angel kneels beseechingly behind the dying man and directs him towards his only Salvation: a crucifix that stands in front of a window, through which light is streaming. (p. 192) Fischer, 2016 Jheronimus Bosch #319 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser The iconography of this representation of a miser who has reached his final hour has been compared with pictures from the Ars moriendi tradition and illustrations of pointless wealth[Morganstern, 1982, 33-41; Morganstern, 1984, 295-302; Marijnissen, 1972; Marijnissen, 1977; Marijnissen, 1987; Vinken & Schlüter, 2000, 69-78; Colenbrander, 2003, 22-32]. Areas of overlap can be found in the dying man’s confrontation, for on last time, with the temptations that have ruled his life, here represented by devils, exempla and symbolic objects, and the promise of salvation extended by the Church, in the shape of clerics, angels, saints and Christ. (pp. 256-257) Fischer, 2016 Jheronimus Bosch #336 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser Bosch also did not ignore the worldly side of the temptation to commit deadly sins. For avarice, he depicted The Death of a Miser on a panel that was surely the shutter of a triptych configuration, viewed obliquely leftwards in terms of its perspective [Marijnissen, 2007, 320-324]. The dying man lies in his bed amidst a cluttered room of stored legal papers with seals, knightly armour and bags of money in locked chests, Demons hover around all of these worldly trophies, and a second standing old figure, despite a rosary at his waist, holds a coin in his hand above a moneybag. One other demon at this last moment still offers the dying old man a moneybag, to which he reaches even now. At the same time, he stares obsessively at the shrouded, skeletal figure of Death in the open doorway, who bears a mortal arrow aimed at him. Consequently both of these conflicting preoccupations preclude the old man from seeing what viewers can – namely, a guardian angel behind him, who attempts to redirect his vision upwards to the window above that doorway, where divine light enters the room across a hanging crucifix. Even at the very last moment, demons and worldly temptations can distract errant humanity into deadly sin, here avarice. Scholars have rightly invoked the fifteenth-century text Ars moriendi (How to die) [Ars moriendi, ca. 1415-1450], where a Christian on his deathbed is tempted to sin by demons but is ultimately consoled and saved by Christ and his angelic forces [Tentler, 2005; Olds, 1966; Ariès, 1981, 107-110]. (p. 129) Silver, 2017 Crimes and Punishments. Bosch’s Hell #337 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser Here, as in The Death of a Miser, Bosch uses daily life events with ordinary figures to convey his moral instruction, but he frames these actions within the all-seeing eye of God (just as he uses demons, Death and an angel in the Miser). (p. 130) Silver, 2017 Crimes and Punishments. Bosch’s Hell #358 Figure with arrow behind door from Death and the Miser The Grim Reaper, holding an arrow, has just opened the door, signalling the old man’s last hour. (p. 298) Lammertse, 2017 Hieronymus Bosch: The pilgrimage of life triptych #360 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser The composition recalls illustrations in the Ars moriendi manuals – popular in Bosch’s day- which taught readers the art of dying. A typical illustration in such a book presented a man on his deathbed, with a devil tempting him into choosing material things and an angel pointing out that there is still time to repent and that the dying man’s eternal salvation is much more important than his worldly goods. The Washington panel can be compared to the depiction of a dying man with both a devil and an angel sitting on the headboard of his bed on The Table of the Seven Deadly Sins [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510; Hand & Wolff, 1986; Lammertse & van der Coelen, 2015, 62; Ilsink et al., 2016, 212-215]. (p. 298) Lammertse, 2017 Hieronymus Bosch: The pilgrimage of life triptych #385 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser Bosch champions a quietist attitude: do nor pursue the things of this world – money, possessions and pleasure because the reward will be eternal damnation. A similar idea is expressed in Death and the Usurer… The dying man originally clutched a precious chalice, which was only executed in the underdrawing. The chalice and the money-bags recall a passage from the Middle Dutch ‘Book of God’s Providence’ [Faris, 1914], in which a section with ‘instructive examples’ refers to a rich man who speaks the following words on his deathbed: Fetch my money and see if it can help me, as I hope. The money was duly brought to him and the rich man spoke again: Oh, my money, can ‘t you help me not to die, for you know how much I love you in order to get you, and I took great care of you, wherever I was.’ When his money proves unable to help him, he has ‘all of his jewels and silver dishes’ brought to him. And these cannot save him either, he bites a dish and dies. (p. 136) Koldeweij, Vandenbroeck & Vermet, 2001 Hieronymus Bosch. The Complete Paintings and Drawings #386 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser Various 15th-century Ars moriendi books ( on the subject of dying and death) describe how the devil encourages dying people to worry about their money. Similar deathbed images occur very frequently in 15th-century Books of Hours, such as the Hours of Catherine of Cleves (which also has a man placing something in or removing something from a treasure-chest in the foreground) [”Deathbed, from The Hours of Catherine of Cleves”, ca. 1440], of Rohan (with Death entering a barrel-vaulted room holding an arrow and coffin) [”Death, from Grandes heures de Rohan”, ca. 1401-1500] and the Hours of Margaret of York (with similarities of composition co Bosch’s scene – the four-poster bed and the striking foreshortening of the barrel-vaulted room) [Follower of Dreux Jean, ca. 1468-1477]. Bosch evidently drew inspiration from a miniature of this type. (p. 136) Koldeweij, Vandenbroeck & Vermet, 2001 Hieronymus Bosch. The Complete Paintings and Drawings #387 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser The general character of the panel has always been understood – the dying man between the angel (pointing towards the crucifix in the window and the ray of light ic emits), Death (entering the room) and demons. One demon offers him a money-bag, another holds up a document, a third disappears beneath the treasure chest, another sits inside it, a fifth leans its head melancholically on the low wall at the front, while a final demon sits on the canopy of the bed with a brazier. The overall theme is plainly avarice. (p. 136) Koldeweij, Vandenbroeck & Vermet, 2001 Hieronymus Bosch. The Complete Paintings and Drawings #461 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser That man persists in his folly even at the moment of death, when the eternities of Heaven and Hell hang in the balance, is the subject of the Death of the Miser. The dying man lies in a high, narrow bedchamber, into which Death has already entered at the left. His guardian angel supports him and attempts to draw his attention to the crucifix in the window above, but he is still distracted by the earthly possessions he must leave behind; one hand reaches out almost automatically to clutch the bag of gold offered by a demon through the curtain. Another demon, delicately winged, leans on the ledge in the foreground, where the rich robes and knightly equipment probably allude to the worldly rank and power which the miser must also abandon. The battle of angels and devils for the soul of the dying man occurs also in the Prado Tabletop (where the traditional figure of Death armed with an arrow likewise appears), and both scenes reflect a popular fifteenth-century devotional work [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510], the Ars moriendi or Craft of Dying [Ars moriendi, ca. 1415-1450], which was printed many times in Germany and the Netherlands. (p. 46) Gibson, 1973 Hieronymus Bosch #473 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser The painting shows a dying man seated in a testered bed set in a bare, narrow room. The figure of Death as a skeleton carrying an arrow enters at the left. Accompanying the dying man are a demon holding a sack and an angel who urges him to recognize the crucifix in the upper window. At the foot of the bed another figure stands next to an open chest and puts money into a sack held by a demon. In the foreground a demon leans on a low wall, his head supported by his hand in a gesture of melancholy. On the spectator’s side of the wall are pieces of armor and weapons; a cloak and a sleeved garment are draped over the wall. (p. 17) Hand & Wolff, 1986 Early Netherlandish Painting #474 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser The consensus among critics is that the painting represents the death of a miser. Further, most authors have agreed with de Tolnay’s initial assessment that the subject is based on the text and images of the Ars moriendi [Ars moriendi, ca. 1415-1450]. There is, however, no agreement on the overall iconographie program of the painting, its exact relationship to the Ars moriendi, or the interpretation of various details… Bosch’s awareness of the visual tradition of the Ars moriendi [Ars moriendi, ca. 1415-1450] can be seen, first, in the roundel showing Death as one of the Four Last Things in the Tabletop in the Prado, Madrid [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510; de Tolnay, 1966, 15-16]. (p. 17) Hand & Wolff, 1986 Early Netherlandish Painting #476 Figure with arrow behind door from Death and the Miser There are many points of correspondence between Bosch’s painting and Ars moriendi images, such as the figure of Death as a shrouded skeleton, the juxtaposition of angel and devil on the headboard of the bed, and the oblique angle of the bed [Ars moriendi, ca. 1415-1450]. (pp. 17-18) Hand & Wolff, 1986 Early Netherlandish Painting #477 Winged figure behind man of his deathbed from Death and the Miser There are many points of correspondence between Bosch’s painting and Ars moriendi images, such as the figure of Death as a shrouded skeleton, the juxtaposition of angel and devil on the headboard of the bed, and the oblique angle of the bed [Ars moriendi, ca. 1415-1450]. (pp. 17-18) Hand & Wolff, 1986 Early Netherlandish Painting #478 Figure above bedboard from Death and the Miser There are many points of correspondence between Bosch’s painting and Ars moriendi images, such as the figure of Death as a shrouded skeleton, the juxtaposition of angel and devil on the headboard of the bed, and the oblique angle of the bed [Ars moriendi, ca. 1415-1450]. (pp. 17-18) Hand & Wolff, 1986 Early Netherlandish Painting #479 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser The relationship of Death and the Miser to the Ars moriendi is less direct than that of the Prado Tabletop [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510, “The Seven Deadly Sins and the Four Last Things”]. In place of discrete, opposing images Bosch seems to have conflated scenes of the temptation by and triumph over avarice and introduced an element of suspense. The miser seems to ignore both the guardian angel who offers salvation and the toadlike demon who pops through the bed-curtain with a sack that almost certainly contains either money or gold. Instead, the dying man is transfixed by the figure of Death who, as in the Prado Tabletop, is represented as a shrouded skeleton holding an arrow. As with the Ars moriendi images [Ars moriendi, ca. 1415-1450], demons scurry under the furniture or peer down at the dying man from the bed canopy. While the outcome of the struggle may not be immediately apparent, other elements in the scene show the dying man to be guilty of the sin of avarice, the last temptation mentioned in the Ars moriendi. (p. 18) Hand & Wolff, 1986 Early Netherlandish Painting #509 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser That man persists in his folly even at the moment of death, when the eternities of Heaven and Hell hang in the balance, is the subject of the Death of the Miser. The dying man lies in a high, narrow bedchamber, into which Death has already entered at the left. His guardian angel supports him and attempts to draw his attention to the crucifix in the window above, but he is still distracted by the earthly possessions he must leave behind; one hand reaches out almost automatically to clutch the bag of gold offered by a demon through the curtain. Another demon, delicately winged, leans on the ledge in the foreground, where the rich robes and knightly equipment probably allude to the worldly rank and power which the miser must also abandon. The battle of angels and devils for the soul of the dying man occurs also in the Prado Tabletop (where the traditional figure of Death armed with an arrow likewise appears), and both scenes reflect a popular fifteenth-century devotional work [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510], the Ars moriendi or Craft of Dying [Ars moriendi, ca. 1415-1450], which was printed many times in Germany and the Netherlands. (p. 32) Bosing, 1987 Hieronymus Bosch c.1450-1516 #511 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser Death, no less then folly, was a major preoccupation of the waning Middgle Ages. The fashionable court poets dwelt upon the dissolution of the flesh and of all fair things in this world. It was also the theme of countless treatises of moral instruction, and the same morbid interest appears in the decaying corpses who seized their victims in scenes of the Dance of Death or recline on sculptured tombs. “I was as you are now, you will be I am”, they seem to say the living, repeating a favourite phrase of the period. But this obsession with death was compounded by a still greater horror: the firm conviction that after the physical dissolution of the body, the soul, continued to exist, possibly doomed to eternal suffering in Hell. And it is in the depiction of the afterlife of the soul and its torments that Bosch made perhaps his most significant contribution to the history of painting. (p. 32) Bosing, 1987 Hieronymus Bosch c.1450-1516 #521 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser This is the first of the Four Last Things: Death, Judgment, Hell, Heaven. But simple comparison with the deathbed scene in the roundel on The Seven Deadly Sins [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510] shows a great difference. In the earlier work the dying man is surrounded by familiars and priests in prayer; here he is abandoned to his own choices. The angel pointing the way to Heaven has just as little hold over him as the gray devil who pops up from under the bed curtain to offer him a sack of gold: he has eyes only for the arrow that Death points at him from the half-opened door. A miser is dying, but the weak and indecisive movements of his arms and hands make it all too evident that he is the very last to understand that even now it is not too late to choose between damnation and a friendlier afterlife. Everything here seems slippery and unsure. (p. 63) Linfert, 1989 Hieronymus Bosch #556 Wooden gate with ox and bird from The Pedlar His end will be the gallows, to be seen beyond the gate he is about to pass [Philip, 1958]. (p. 112) Cinotti, 1966 The complete paintings of Bosch #560 Boat with ten people onboard from Ship of Fools The Cathars did not believe that the material body would ever be resurrected. According to their doctrines, it was discarded forever at death and it dissolved into its original elements [Ivanov, 1976, 180ff]. Bosch illustrates this last idea by the half-submerged ship in the distance. This physical boat (the body) sinks back into the waters of the material world, much as Bosch’s ships of fools might, if they were abandoned by their passengers [Harris, 1995, 201 – 214; Allberry, 1938, 139, 147, 217, 218] (p.179) Harris, 1995 The secret heresy of Hieronymus Bosch #577 Hat on left hand from The Pedlar The spinder in the hat held out by the Hearer in the panel at Rotterdam is a traditional symbol of the weaving of the thread of physical life. Only one small strand remains on it, and as Wertheim says, this is probably a sign that the peddler has very little left on earth. Alternatively, in the interpretation of Stein Schneider, the spindle itself is an image of continuing death and rebirth, which implies reincarnation [Wertheim Aymès, 1957, 39; Schneider, 1984, 59f.; Cooper, 1982, 170]. Perhaps Bosch is expressing both ideas. In any case, the gallows on the hill behind the gate and spindle warns us that the pilgrim will suffer spiritual death if his desires lead to his rebirth in the physical world. the gallows on the hill behind the gate and spindle warns us that the pilgrim will suffer spiritual death if his desires lead to his rebirth in the physical world. (p. 165) Harris, 1995 The secret heresy of Hieronymus Bosch #578 Landscape background from The Pedlar … the gallows on the hill behind the gate… warns us that the pilgrim will suffer spiritual death if his desires lead to his rebirth in the physical world. (p. 165) Harris, 1995 The secret heresy of Hieronymus Bosch #579 Wooden gate with ox and bird from The Pedlar … the gallows on the hill behind the gate… warns us that the pilgrim will suffer spiritual death if his desires lead to his rebirth in the physical world. In the Haywain panels [Bosch, ca. 1512-1515], the same danger is suggested by the crack, implying the possibility of breakage, on the stone bridge which the wayfarer is about to cross. Even the stone gateposts in the painting at Rotterdam repeat the message. Close examination reveals that one of these is cracked and crumbling, while the other is firm and unblemished. (p. 165) Harris, 1995 The secret heresy of Hieronymus Bosch #580 Ragged poor man from The Pedlar The spinder in the hat held out by the Hearer in the panel at Rotterdam is a traditional symbol of the weaving of the thread of physical life. Only one small strand remains on it, and as Wertheim says, this is probably a sign that the peddler has very little left on earth. Alternatively, in the interpretation of Stein Schneider, the spindle itself is an image of continuing death and rebirth, which implies reincarnation [Wertheim Aymès, 1957, 39; Stein-Schneider, 1984, 59f.; Cooper, 1982, 170]. Perhaps Boseh is expressing both ideas. In any case, the gallows on the hill behind the gate and spindle warns us that the pilgrim will suffer spiritual death if his desires lead to his rebirth in the physical world. the gallows on the hill behind the gate and spindle warns us that the pilgrim will suffer spiritual death if his desires lead to his rebirth in the physical world. In any case, the gallows on the hill behind the gate and spindle warns us that the pilgrim will suffer spiritual death if his desires lead to his rebirth in the physical world. In the Haywain panels [Bosch, ca. 1512-1515], the same danger is suggested by the crack, implying the possibility of breakage, on the stone bridge which the wayfarer is about to cross. Even the stone gateposts in the painting at Rotterdam repeat the message. Close examination reveals that one of these is cracked and crumbling, while the other is firm and unblemished. This contrast symbolizes the peddler’s choice between salvation in the world of light, and rebirth into hell (the Cathar name for the earth). (p. 165) Harris, 1995 The secret heresy of Hieronymus Bosch #593 Owl in the tree from The Pedlar “High time to get away from here!” scolds the owl from the tree, angrily ruffling its feathers – not the devil’s whisk Baldass takes it for, but the bird of wisdom, which Bosch’s symbolism regularly stands for knowledge and mastery of death [Baldass, 1943]. (p. 258) Fraenger, 1999 Hieronymus Bosch #623 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser The Hour Death (p. 298) Fraenger, 1999 Hieronymus Bosch #624 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser the slender Hour of Death panel formerly in the van der Elst collection, now in the National Gallery, Washington, D. C., creates through its very format a feeling of terrible constriction, intensified by the narrow room receding into depths of darkness. (p. 298) Fraenger, 1999 Hieronymus Bosch #630 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser At this moment Death, pale in his tight lemuric shroud, sidles in through the barely open door whose narrow opening intensifies the cramped oppressiveness of the room, aiming his arrow – its shadow gliding ahead of it-at the deathbed. Between Death and his victim the bulging, tucked-up bed curtain sags with the menacing heaviness of doom. In this stage setting even the incidental props are used to create mood. (p. 299) Fraenger, 1999 Hieronymus Bosch #631 Crucifix on window from Death and the Miser Above Death’s door is a window with a crucifix set in it. The slightly open door is precisely aligned with the window embrasure; together with the column they form a solid vertical structure. In this way Death is consigned to a closely confined area on the edge of existence. Furthermore a brilliant ray of light falling from the crucifix upon the dying man as a reminder of eternal life overcomes Death’s shadowy arrow, showing that his power is limited to the earthly realm. (p. 299) Fraenger, 1999 Hieronymus Bosch #633 Vaulted ceiling from Death and the Miser The domain of approaching Death begins only under the vaulted ceiling, which is divided into four regular panels by five hanging thyrsus-pinecones and four bare ribs. Another striking feature is the neatly drawn series of fourteen parallel lines between molding and vertex on the left side of the vault, symmetrically repeated on the right side. (p. 299) Fraenger, 1999 Hieronymus Bosch #643 Crucifix on window from Death and the Miser Interceding grace emanating from above takes away sin, as the beam of light from the crucified Christ overcomes the “sting of death” [English Standard Version Bible, 2001, I Corinthians, 15:55-56] and robs Hell of its victory. (p. 300) Fraenger, 1999 Hieronymus Bosch #664 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser ‘Who dieth well, his grave’s the best/ The sinner’s death is never blest’ is another fine couplet from Brant’s Ship of Fools [Brant, 1962, 283]. It offers a nice introduction to the dilemma facing the protagonist of the right wing of the Wayfarer Triptych. A man sits up in bed, looking into the eyes of Death, who appears from behind the door. Death points an oversized arrow directly at him. It is time. The final hour has come. The question now is whether the dying man will grasp the bag held out to him by a demon from beneath the curtain of the bed. The answer to this question will determine the man’s fate: is it to be heaven or hell? An angel behind him tries to draw his attention to the image of a crucifix that appears in the window in the upper left corner. The rays of light that enter the room via the crucified Christ do not (yet) extend, however, as far as the dying man. The struggle between the angel and the devil, who has positioned himself on the canopy of the bed in the hope that the man will make the wrong choice, has not been settled. The wing encourages us to think about what we would do in the face of death: hold on or let go. (p. 328) Ilsink et al., 2016 Hieronymus Bosch. Painter and Draughtsman #667 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser The combination of the well-filled money-chest and the approach of death does not feature in what was probably another important source for Bosch in this case, namely the illustrations in the Ars moriendi, a treatise on the ‘Art of Dying’. The book was printed frequently in the Low Countries and the neighbouring regions at the end of the fifteenth century, and was available in both Latin and vernacular editions [”Ars moriendi (Cologne)”, 1474; van Os, 1488; Snellaert, 1488; Leeu, 1492]. Its purpose was to help people prepare for a ‘virtuous death’, to which end it included eleven full-page woodcut illustrations, each showing a man on his deathbed. (p. 330) Ilsink et al., 2016 Hieronymus Bosch. Painter and Draughtsman #668 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser Bosch’s artistic challenge was to express the dying man’s dilemma in a single image rather than a series of illustrations. He places greater responsibility than the Ars moriendi does, moreover, on the man himself. It is up to him to choose. The choice between moneybag and crucifix has not yet been made: Bosch leaves the viewer with a cliff-hanger. It is evident from the painting’s underdrawing that the artist initially had a simpler image in mind. The man’s hand was originally clamped around the moneybag, and he also held a costly jar in his left hand. The painter evidently decided that this solution was too one-dimensional, as he ultimately omitted the jar, while the dying man in the painting has not yet grabbed the bag. This makes the miser slightly less miserly, while introducing an element of suspense to the struggle for the man’s salvation. In the earlier configuration, the demon looking down from the canopy of the bed would have got its way, and the dying man’s soul would have been lost. In the current form of the painting, by contrast, there is still some hope for the man in the bed. The decision has yet to be taken. (p. 330) Ilsink et al., 2016 Hieronymus Bosch. Painter and Draughtsman #711 Pole in background from The Pedlar At the right hand side of the Peddler, there is a pole represented in the background standing on the yellow hills of a waste land with a bare and dead tree in front of it. That this is a place of execution is beyond doubt. The pole in the background is a wheel and corresponds to the small wheels and gallows which seem to have appeared also in the other compositions of Bosch’s series. This place of execution does not only occur in the Peddler but also in the background of some copies of the Conjurer [Bosch, ca. 1475] and in the background of the copies of the Stone-Operation [Bosch, ca. 1501-1505]. It is evident that Bosch meant to show that all four of the evil characters of his series will finally end on the gallows. (p. 71) Philip, 1958 The Peddler by Hieronymus Bosch, a study in detectio #712 Bird on wooden gate or fence from The Pedlar The gate shows one particular feature which is striking and unusal. It stands by itself without being connected to a fence. From a practical point of view it does not have the function of a gate at all. That Bosch represented the gate as being set up in the landscape as a single to have something to do with the symbolic meaning of object standing free in its surroundings it probably symbolizes something which stands by itself in the landscape. In order to find could be, we should look at the design of the gate in which we look at the particular type of puzzle-picture called Vexier-Bild. Then we see that the wooden parts of it form a perfect image of are, in fact, several little gallows hidden in the design of the gate. and one can see a picture of this ominous object almost any way one looks at it [Philip, 1958, 72:note 153]. The magpie sitting on the gate confirms this interpretation. One is reminded of Bruegel’s painting called The Magpie on the Gallows , which idea originally invented by Bosch [Philip, 1958, 72:note 154; Grossmann, 1955, fig.91, 153-154; Bruegel, 1565; Visscher, 1614; Brummel, 1949, 67]… The gate in the Peddler is indubitably meant to be the Gate of Death [Visscher, 1614], the gallows in disguise. In this painting the place of execution is not only represented as a small ground. The gallows appears as a large image in the foreground, idea of the end on the gallows is particularly stressed in part of the main action and is not shown as only a final distant future. (p. 72) Philip, 1958 The Peddler by Hieronymus Bosch, a study in detectio #714 Cow (Ox) from The Pedlar The steer, the ox and the aurochs can stand for the idea of Death. This is a familiar and well documented symbolic meaning of the animal [de Mély, 1904, 296f.; Cuttler, 1957, 119, note 72; Laborde, 1923]. Oxen occur in this particular meaning, for instance, in the series of Italian prints which were previously discussed as possible models for study [Philip, 1958, 4:note 7-8, 4:note 10, 7:note 20, 12:note 30, 74:note 157; Galle, ca. 1565; Essling & Müntz, 1902, 168-173; Wierix, ca. 1604]. In the story-telling context of Bosch’s painting the ox undoubtedly signifies Death. (p. 74) Philip, 1958 The Peddler by Hieronymus Bosch, a study in detectio #715 Hat on left hand from The Pedlar Even the hat which the peddler holds in his hand takes on a meaning connected with Death when seen together with the gate and the animal. These three symbols occur in a clearly demarcated section and form a unit when one looks at them as details appearing dimensional plane [Philip, 1953, 277f.]. As was shown by Bax and again by Vinken, the representation of the hat which is not on the wearer’s head, can signify that its owner is uncovered, i.e. unprotected, in Dutch “buten hoede”, that there is nothing he can do against a certain danger. On the basis of a Bruegel painting Vinken has clearly proved that this danger is Death [Bax, 1949, 224; Bax, 1953, 200; Vinken, 1958, 4]. The hat in Bosch’s representation is thus another symbol pointing to the peddler’s imminent doom. (p. 74) Philip, 1958 The Peddler by Hieronymus Bosch, a study in detectio #719 Ragged poor man from The Pedlar Bosch’s painting of the Peddler is a representation of the Melancholic which is firmly based on the traditional negative concept of this humor in the middle ages [Panofsky, Giehlow & Saxl, 1923, 21f., 27]… Bosch’s lonely Melancholic shown in his life-journey leading to disgraceful death, is the personification of the Saturnian vices of lethargy and misanthropy. To the middle ages these were the two deadly sins of acedia and invidia, concepts which were not only closely connected with the idea of melancholia but partly even identical with it [Panofsky, Giehlow & Saxl, 1923, 30f.; Bloomfield, 1952, 428, note 30; Philip, 1953, 289, note 95; Philip, 1958, 51:note 115, 75:note 163]. (p. 75) Philip, 1958 The Peddler by Hieronymus Bosch, a study in detectio #742 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser In light of contemporary doctrine, the moment chosen by Bosch to portray the miser is even more critical, and his predicament more serious than had he been merely avaricious. He is placed between Death at the door, the devil with the money bag, and the angel at his side. His eye is fixed on the figure of Death [de Tolnay, 1937, 27; de Tolnay, 1966], whose arrow he seems to ward off with his left hand, while gesturing toward the money bag held by the devil with his right [Eisler, 1977, 68]. (pp. 36-37) Morganstern, 1982 The Pawns in Bosch’s” Death and the Miser” #743 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser An infrared photograph of the painting shows a change in the area of the left hand [Eisler, 1977, 66; “Detail, infrared reflectogram image of Death and the Miser”, 1982]. In the underdrawing, the hand was extended further and held a covered goblet, as if offering it to Death [Morganstern, 1982, 40:note 30; Frankfurter, 1952, 114; Friedländer, 1969, 33; Master of the Virgin among Virgins, ca. 1490; van Oostsanen, 1517; Kohlhaussen, 1968, pp. 348f., no. 386]. The gesture toward the money bag accompanied this present and was thus also probably originally intended as an offering to Death. By painting out the goblet and shortening Death’s arrow, Bosch increased the tension between the miser and the figure of Death. Death. But did he intend to change the meaning? I think not. The gesture toward the money bag remains a gesture of offering. Our miser may be like the dying man cited by Tervarent, who showed Death his treasures, requesting that he take them with him [de Tervarent, 1945, 44f.].Or he may be offering Death a ransom. In either case, he seems preoccupied with the approach of Death on the one hand and with his gold on the other. There is no indication that he has thought of making restitution to the debtors whose pawns litter courtyard, and he seems totally unaware of the beam of light streaming through the window. No wonder the angel’s gesture is so urgent. He can only plead for mercy for this helpless sinner, who even at the moment of death seems unable to extricate himself from his possessions. (p. 37) Morganstern, 1982 The Pawns in Bosch’s” Death and the Miser” #745 Knightly jousting objects, draped cloth with winged figure from Death and the Miser …the objects strewn in the foreground of Bosch’s Death and the Miser are directly related to its main theme, the death of an avaricious old man. (p. 37) Morganstern, 1982 The Pawns in Bosch’s” Death and the Miser” #776 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser Der “Tod des Geizigen” schließlich zeigt einen alten Mann (als Sinnbild der “avaritia”), der sich von seinen Reichtümern löst. Mehrere Stufen des Seelenkampfes werden geschildert, teufl ische Dämonen umgeben sein Sterbebett, und ein Engel weist auf das Kreuz Christi hin. (p. 182) Hartau (Suche nach Glück bei nahem Untergang), 2001 Suche nach Glück bei nahem Untergang #811 Man on a barrel with five skinny men in the waters from An Allegory of Intemperance … the Death and the Usurer, unambiguously evokes the late medieval Ars moriendi (Art of Dying [Well) [van Os, 1488] by placing a skeletal figure of Death at the door while an angel and a demon contend for the soul of the expiring old man. In the Prado tabletop of the Seven Deadly Sins [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510], luxuria not only is labeled clearly on the panel but also appears among the other deadly sins, enframed by the Four Last Things: Death (echoing the Washington Usurer panel), Last Judgment, Heaven, and Hell. (p. 29) Silver, 2006 Hieronymus Bosch #819 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser …this combination of riches and demons derives from me fifteen century pictorial tradition of me Ars moriendi (The Art of Dying [Well]), an advice treatise – particularly popular in both Latin and the vernacular during the early decades of printed books – that presents a series of temptations to sin at the deathbed of an individual [O’Connor, 1942; Tenenti, 1952, 98-108; Mâle, 1908, 348-355; Ariès, 1981, 107-110, 128-130; Binski, 1996, 39-43]. Significantly, this text is addressed to an individual layman and suggests the value of a deathbed conversion and personal reform. Altogether the text progresses through a series of five temptations – unbelief, despair, impatience, pride and avarice – with five Christian responses to combat them, followed by a final set piece of the good death and its promise of ultimate salvation. (pp. 239-240) Silver, 2006 Hieronymus Bosch #821 Old man in green and chest from Death and the Miser Bosch has conflated items of both pride and avarice, for besides tile riches held at the fingertips of the dying man in his very deathbed, at the foot of the bed a second figure (either a companion or the same old man at an earlier moment) inspects a wooden chest containing more possessions, ranging from more money bags to sealed legal documents, all surrounded by bestial winged demons. (p. 240) Silver, 2006 Hieronymus Bosch #823 Figure with arrow behind door from Death and the Miser Despite the relative animation of the old man in his bed the nemesis figure of Death appears in the doorway as a skeleton in a shroud. As he opens the door, Death reaches into the room, pointing an arrow held in his right hand in the direction of the dying miser. Pentimenti reveal that the arrow was originally intended to extend farther, almost to the edge of the bed, stopping just before the edge of the pillow above the head of the demon. Their physical confrontation marks tlus encounter as the most feared of late-medieval deaths, the sudden death, not prepared for with repentance and confession to provide absolution for sins. Indeed, so strong was this fear that St. Christopher was often invoked as the patron saint to protect against sudden, unprepared death and its attendant danger of danmation. In fact, enormous wall paintings of the giant Christopher often appeared on church walls, even on outside walls, in order to provide a ready and accessiblc image for prophylaxis [Dolan, 1964, 60]. (p. 242) Silver, 2006 Hieronymus Bosch #824 Crucifix on window from Death and the Miser Bosch also includes the angelic component of the Ars moriendi. Behind the back of the old man in the bed kneels a guardian angel, whose hand rests upon his shoulder. The angel gazes upward and gestures with his right hand toward the upper left corner of the chamber. There a small, lone window admits a bean of light from heaven, which passes downward through the narrow opening and past a crucifix to fall upon the old man in the bed. However, the sudden appearance of Death at his door has transfixed the old man’s own gaze directly across from him and absorbs his full attention, thus preventing him from beholding either the light or the crucifix above. (p. 242) Silver, 2006 Hieronymus Bosch #829 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser A similar juxtaposition of a skeletal Death with a grasping miser with his treasures, including coins on the table, reappears in the woodcut The Miser from Hans Holbein’s series of images of all classes and ranks, The Dance of Death, published in Lyons in 1538 but designed and cut as woodblocks for prints in Basel around 1525 [Holbein, ca. 1523 – 1525; Parshall, 2001]. (p. 242) Silver, 2006 Hieronymus Bosch