Home ➞ Iconology ➞ Interpretations Iconology of the Wayfarer Triptych Table View Explore by: # Keywords⚆ Visual Attributes Iconology - Filter Painting An Allegory of Intemperance Death and the Miser Ship of Fools The Pedlar Visual Objects Carried out by Category Aspects of time Bible and biblical stories Christianity and the Church Earth and world Human being and life Intention, will and state of being Literary and mythical characters and objects Morality and immorality Non-Christian religions Planets and zodiacal signs Reasoning, judgement and intelligence Scientific perspectives and methods Social conduct and emotions Social life, culture and activities Society and social classes Supernaturalism and magic Keywords Lust (Luxuria) Refers to "Carrus Navalis in Schönbartbuch", 16th century "Carrus Navalis in Schönbartbuch", 1908 "Death, from Grandes heures de Rohan", ca. 1401-1500 "Deathbed, from The Hours of Catherine of Cleves", ca. 1440 "de l’ouïe et du goût", ca. 1510-1520 "Detail, infrared reflectogram image of Death and the Miser", 1982 "Flight into Egypt", ca. 1500 "La barque d’Ëve", ca. 1510-1520 "May, from Hours of Joanna I of Castile", ca. 1486-1506 "Pedlar, from The Luttrell Psalter", ca. 1325-1340 "Psalter of Eleanor of Aquitaine", ca. 1185 "Reconstruction of Ship of Fools after Seymour", 1984 "Saturn, from Astrological treatises", 15th century "Saturn and his children, from Passauer Calendar", 1445 "Terra, from Engelberg Crucifix", ca. 1200 "The Tree of Life", 1502 Abraham, Levy & Cantera, 1939 Adhémar, 1962 Aertsen, 1556 Aesop, ca. 1501 Agrippa, 1910 Ainsworth, 2010 Ainsworth et al., 2012 Alexandre, 1892 Allberry, 1938 Allegory of Chasity at the Bardi Chapel, ca. 1325 Altdorfer, ca. 1515-1516 Anthonisz, 1541 Antoninus, 1449 Antwerper Liedboek, 1544 Ariès, 1981 Ars moriendi, ca. 1415-1450 Ars moriendi, ca. 1474 Atkins, 2017 Augustodunensis, ca. 1080-1156 Avé-Lallemant, 1858 Badius, 1498 Badius, 1498 (Frontispiece) Badius, 1500 Badius, 1502 Baldass, 1926 Baldass, 1938 Baldass, 1943 Baldass, 1959 Baldass, 1968 Baldini, ca. 1464 Baltrusaitis, 1955 Barbado, 1931 Bass & Wyckoff, 2015 Bauer, 1989 Bax, 1948 Bax, 1949 Bax, 1953 Bax, 1962 Bax, 1979 Bayley, 1919 Bayot, 1929 Beagle, 1982 Bedaux & Ekkart, 2000 Beer, 1957 Beets, 1938 Beets, 1946 Beets, 1954 Beham, 1535 Beham, ca. 1530-1562 Bellaert, 1486 Benesch, 1937 Benesch, 1957 Bening, 1500 Bening, ca. 1515 Bening, ca. 1530 Bergmans, 1936 Bevers, 1986 Bidez & Cumont, 1938 Biesheuvel, 2005 Bigwood, 1921 Binski, 1996 Bishop, 1918 Bisschop & Verwijs, 1870 Bloch, 1912 Bloemaert, After 1635 Bloomfield, 1952 Boczkowska, 1971 Bohnert, 1985 Boll & Bezold, 1931 Boll, 1913 Bolswert, ca. 1610-1620 Bonenfant, 1958 Boon, 1968 Bosch, 15th century Bosch, 16th century Bosch, ca. 1475 Bosch, ca. 1475-1500 Bosch, ca. 1485 Bosch, ca. 1485-1490 Bosch, ca. 1490-1495 Bosch, ca. 1490-1500 Bosch, ca. 1494 (Ecce Homo) Bosch, ca. 1494 (Triptych of Adoration of the Magi) Bosch, ca. 1495–1500 Bosch, ca. 1498 Bosch, ca. 1500 Bosch, ca. 1500 (Johannes auf Patmos) Bosch, ca. 1500 (Temptations of St. Anthony) Bosch, ca. 1500 (The Pedlar) Bosch, ca. 1501-1505 Bosch, ca. 1504-1508 Bosch, ca. 1505 Bosch, ca. 1505-1510 Bosch, ca. 1510 Bosch, ca. 1512-1515 Bosch, ca. 1520-1545 Boschère, 1947 Bosing, 1987 Brabant, ca. 1460 Brands, 1921 Brans, 1948 Brant, 1494 Brant, 1498 Brant, 1498 (Frontispiece) Brant, 1500 Brant, 1854 Brant, 1944 Brant, 1962 Brant, 2011 Briffault, 1927 Brion, 1938 Brody, 1974 Bruegel, 1559 (Die niederländischen Sprichwörter) Bruegel, 1559 (Misanthropist) Bruegel, 1559 (The Fight between Carnival and Lent) Bruegel, 1562 Bruegel, 1564 Bruegel, 1565 Bruegel, 1565 (Der Frühling) Bruegel, 1567 Bruegel, 1568 Bruegel, 1568 (Les Mendiants ou Les Culs-de-jatte) Bruegel, 1568 (The Blind Leading the Blind) Bruegel, 1568 (The Magpie on the Gallows) Bruegel, 1574 Bruegel, ca. 1600-1624 Brummel, 1949 Bunyan, 1678 Burlington Fine Arts Club, 1908 Buytewech, ca. 1591-1624 Bücken & Steyaert, 2013 Calkins, 1978 Carefree living, ca. 1560 Cartellieri, 1929 Cats, 1642 Chailley, 1978 Chew, 1962 Ciceron, 1938 Cinotti, 1966 Cirlot, 1962 Cluse, 2000 Cohen, 1909 (Die Ausstellung des Goldenen Vlieses in Bru_gge, 1907) Cohen, 1909 (Hieronymus Bosch) Colenbrander, 2003 Combe, 1946 Combe, 1957 Comestor, ca. 1440 Condivi, 1927 Conway, 1921 Cooper, 1982 Crul, 1920 Cumont, 1942 Cuttler, 1957 Cuttler, 1968 Cuttler, 1969 D'Overflacque_e, 1932 Damascenus, 1879 Dante, ca. 1308-1321 Das Schiff der Flust, ca. 1360 da Vinci, ca. 1591-1624 de Beer, 1990 de Boschère, 1947 de Bruyn, 1601 de Bruyn, 1604 de Bruyn, 2001 de Bruyn, 2001 (Hieronymous Bosch's So-Called Prodigal Son Tondo) de Bruyn, 2017 de Cock, 1905 de Coster, 1867 de Diguleville, 1922 de Diguleville, ca. 1330-1331 (Pèlerinage de la vie humaine) de Diguleville, ca. 1330-1331 (Ship of Religion) de Haas, 1942 de Jode, 1590s de Jongh, 2000 de Julleville, 1889 de Laborde, 1929 Delaissé, 1959 Delevoy, 1960 Delevoy, 1990 de Mirimonde, 1971 Demonts, 1919 Demonts, 1920 de Mooij, 1992 de Mély, 1904 Der Melancholiker, 15th century de Roover, 1948 de Roover, 1967 Der verlorene Sohn beim Spiel im Freudenhaus, ca. 1520 de Tervarent, 1945 de Tervarent, 1958 de Tollenaere, 1941 de Tolnay, 1935 de Tolnay, 1937 de Tolnay, 1965 de Tolnay, 1966 Detroit Institute Arts, 1960 Devoghelaere, 1937 De Vos, 1967 Die vier Temperamente, ca. 1481 Dixon, 2003 Dolan, 1964 Donatello, ca. 1457-1464 Drescher, 1908 du Hameel, ca. 1478-1506 Dülberg, 1929 Dürer, 1494 (Frontispiece of Daß Narrenschyff ad Narragoniam) Dürer, 1494 (Of Serenading at Night) Dürer, 1514 Eisler, 1946 Eisler, 1946 (Zodiacal trines) Eisler, 1961 Eisler, 1977 Eliade, 1959 Elst, 1944 Elst, 1946 Encyclopaedia Judaica, 1971 Engler, 1962 English Standard Version Bible, 2001 Enklaar, 1922 Enklaar, 1933 Enklaar, 1937 Enklaar, 1940 Enklaar, 1956 Erasmus, 1828 Erasmus, 1913 Essling & Müntz, 1902 Fabre-Vassas, 1997 Falkenburg, 1988 Faris, 1914 Fierens, 1936 Fierens, 1947 Fischart, 1969 Fischer, 2016 Follower of Dreux Jean, ca. 1468-1477 Follower of Jheronimus Bosch, 15th century Follower of Jheronimus Bosch, ca. 1485-1490 Follower of Jheronimus Bosch, ca. 1555-1575 Follower of Jheronimus Bosch, ca. 1560 Follower of Jheronimus Bosch, ca. 1561 Follower of Pieter Bruegel, ca. 1550-1575 Follower of Pieter Huys, ca. 1560 Fourcaud, 1912 Fraenger, 1930 Fraenger, 1950 Fraenger, 1951 Fraenger, 1975 Fraenger, 1999 Francis, 1942 Frankfurter, 1952 Frey, 1957 Friedländer, 1927 Friedländer, 1935 Friedländer, 1969 Galle, ca. 1565 Ganz, 1924 Gaspar, 1932 Gerlach, 1939 Gerlach, 1978 Gerlach, 1979 Gibson, 1973 Gibson, 1973 (Hieronymus Bosch and the Dutch tradition) Gibson, 1973 (Hieronymus Bosch and the Mirror of Man) Gibson, 1983 Glück, 1904 Glück, 1933 Gossaert, 1919 Gossaert, ca. 1513-1515 Gossart, 1907 Gotthelf, 1948 Grimm, 1911 Gringore, 1512 Grossmann, 1955 Gundel, 1922 Gutekunst, 1899 Gérard, 1486-1487 Habig, 1973 Hals, ca. 1616-1617 Hammerstein, 1962 Hampe, 1902 Hand & Wolff, 1986 Hand, 1965 Hannema, 1931 Hannema, 1936 Hansen, 1984 Harms, 1970 Harrebomée, 1858 Harrebomée, 1861 Harrebomée, 1870 Harris, 1995 Hartau, 2001 Hartau, 2001 (Suche nach Glück bei nahem Untergang) Hartau, 2002 Hartau, 2005 Hartau, 2005 (Bosch and the Jews) Hartmann, 1493 Hauber, 1916 Heidrich, 1910 Heimann, 1990 Heitz, 1906 Hellerstedt, 1986 Hentze, 1932 Heremans, 1877 Hermans, 1867 Hildebrand, 1911 Hildegarde, 1903 Hilka, Schumann & Meyer, 1970 Hind, 1970 Holbein, ca. 1523 - 1525 Hollstein, 1949 Hooffacker, 1988 Horenbout, Bening & Bening, ca. 1510 (Mai) Horenbout, Bening & Bening, ca. 1515–1520 Huebner, 1943 Huebner, 1971 Huizinga, 1919 Hummelen, 1958 Huvenne, 1979 Ilsink, 2013 Ilsink, 2016 Ilsink et al., 2016 Ivanov, 1976 Janson, 1952 Jean de La Fontaine's philosophy, 17th century Jeltes, 1927 Jonas, 1958 Jonas, 1963 Justi, 1908 Kalff, 1884 Kalff, 1907 Kalff, 1923 Kasten, 1992 Kaye, 1998 Kempis, 1505 Klibansky, Panofsky & Saxl, 1964 Kohlhaussen, 1968 Koldeweij, Kooij & Vermet, 2001 Koldeweij, Vandenbroeck & Vermet, 2001 Konneker, 1966 Koomen, 1932 Koreny, 1986 Kozàky, 1944 Kren, McKendrick & Ainsworth, 2003 Kruyskamp, 1940 Labonnardiere, 1957 Laborde, 1923 Lacombe, 1963 Laenen, 1904 Lafond, 1914 Lammertse & van der Coelen, 2015 Lammertse, 1994 Lammertse, 2017 Langendijk, 1715 Laurent, ca. 1290-1300 (Gluttony) Laurent, ca. 1295 (Avarice) Leeber, 1939-1940 Leendertz Jr., 1907 Leendertz Jr., 1925 Leeu, 1492 Lefebvre, 1968 Le Goff, 1979 Lehrs, 1906 Leidinger, 1935 Le Juif errant: un témoin du temps, 2001 Lennep & Gouw, 1868 Le Tavernier & Miélot, ca. 1456 Le Tavernier & Miélot, ca. 1470 Leuvense Bijdragen IV, 1900-1902 Leuvense Bijdragen IX, 1910-1911 Levelt, 1924 Leymarie, 1949 Lindener, 1558 Lindner, 1912 Linfert, 1989 Lippmann, 1895 Liébault, 1582 Lottin, 1950 Lugt, 1968 Lurker, 1960 Lyna & van Eeghem, 1932 Långfors, 1921 Långfors, 1924 Maeterlinck, 1907 Mannhardt, 1858 Marijnissen, 1972 Marijnissen, 1976 Marijnissen, 1977 Marijnissen, 1987 Marijnissen, 2007 Maroto, 2001 Maroto, 2017 Marrow, 1977 Martindale & Bacchesch, 1969 Massys, 16th century Massys, ca. 1520-1525 Master of the Housebook, ca. 1475 Master of the Virgin among Virgins, ca. 1490 Mâle, 1908 Meadow, 1992 Meijer, 1946 Meiss, 1974 (French painting in the time of Jean de Berry) Meiss, 1974 (The Limbourgs and their contemporaries) Mellinkoff, 1993 Meurgey, 1930 Meyling, 1946 Michelangelo, 1533 Millar, 1953 Misero I, ca. 1465 Mollat, 1966 Monogrammist, ca. 1530 Morganstern, 1982 Morganstern, 1984 Moser, 1431 Moser, 1961 Mosmans, 1931 Mosmans, 1947 Moxey, 1985 Moxey, 1989 Müller, 1934 Nahuys, 1888 Nelson, 1969 Neumann, 1950 Neurdenburg, 1910 Nevitt, 2003 Newhauser, 1986 Nichols, 1992 Nielsen, 1904 Noonan, 1957 O'Brien-Moore, 1924 O'Connor, 1942 Offner & Steinweg, 1979 Olds, 1966 Oosterman, 2001 Orenstein, 2001 Owst, 1953 Panofsky & Saxl, 1933 Panofsky, 1939 Panofsky, 1953 Panofsky, Giehlow & Saxl, 1923 Parker, 2020 Parshall, 2001 Petrarch, 1532 Pfister, 1922 Philip, 1953 Philip, 1955 Philip, 1956 Philip, 1958 Philip, 1969 Pigler, 1950 Pleij, 1979 Pleij, 1983 Postan, 1963 Pourbus, c. 1547 Provoost, ca. 1515-1521 Puyvelde, 1956 Pächt, 1948 Pächt, 1950 Quarles, 1638 Quinot, 1962 Rabutaux, 1881 Rembert, 2004 Rembrandt, 1635 Renesse, 1900 Renger, 1969 Renger, 1970 Renger, 1976 Renouard, 1964 Reuterswärd, 1970 Rietstap, 1861 Ritter, Plessner & Mayriti, 1962 Romein & Romein, 1938 Roscher, 1878 Rosenberg, 1961 Rossiter, 1973 Rost, 16th century Rowlands, 1979 Ryckaert, ca. 1649 Saintyves, 1937 Sanger, 1897 Santurn (Lehrs), 15th century Sassen, 1885 Saturn (in Rome manuscript), 16th century Saturn (in Salone di Padua), 12th century Saturn (in Schermermar manuscript), 15th century Saturn and his 'Children' (Panofsky), 15th century Scaha gustationis sultae, 1500 Scháufelein, ca. 1525 Schedel, 1493 Schmitt, 1948 Schoemaker, ca. 1710-1735 Schönsperger, 1922 Schreiber & Zimmermann, 1937 Schreiber, 1926 Schretlen, 1925 Schürmeyer, 1923 Schwartz, 1997 Schwarz & Plagemann, 1937 Seligmann, 1953 Seymour, 1961 Shachar, 1974 Shestack, 1967 Silver, 1977 Silver, 1983 Silver, 1984 Silver, 1996 Silver, 2001 Silver, 2006 Silver, 2006 (Peasant scenes and landscapes) Silver, 2017 Sloet, 1890 Smeyers & Van der Stock, 1996 Smits, 1933 Snellaert, 1488 Solier, 1961 Speculum humanae salvationis, ca. 1466-1467 Spronk, 1998 Steen, ca. 1670 Stein-Schneider, 1984 Stoett, 1932 Stone-Ferrier, 1983 Strauss, 1926 Strauss, 1974 Stridbeck, 1956 Stürzinger, 1893 Suchier & Birch-Hirschfeld, 1913 Sudeck, 1931 Swain, 1932 Swelinck, 1627 Tallqvist, 1948 Tenenti, 1952 Tentler, 2003 Tentler, 2005 Terence, 2nd century BC The eating of the passover lamb, from Historia Scholastica, ca. 1450-1455 Thiele, 1898 Tinbergen, 1907 Titian, 1518 Tóth-Ubbens, 1987 Tuttle, 1981 Tuve, 1966 Universitätsbibliothek Basel & Universitätsbibliothek Freiburg im Breisgau, 1994 Valentiner & Suida, 1949 Valerius, 1942 van Andel, 1928 van Bastelaer, 1908 van Camp, 2017 van den Bossche, 1944 Vandenbroeck, 1981 Vandenbroeck, 1985 Vandenbroeck, 1987 Vandenbroeck, 1987 (Beeld van de andere, vertoog over het zelf) Vandenbroeck, 1989 Vandenbroeck, 2001 Vandenbroeck, 2002 Vandenbroeck, 2017 van der Heyden, 1559 van der Heyden, 1562 van der Heyden, 1562 (Marskramer door apen beroofd) van der Heyden, 1567 van der Heyden, 1570 van der Heyden, ca. 1551-1570 van der Heyden, ca. 1558 van de Venne, ca. 1625 Vandeweghe, 2017 van Dis & Erné, 1939 van Duyse, 1908 van Eyck, 1434 van Hemessen, 1536 van Hemessen, 1543 van Hemessen, ca. 1540 van Leyden, 1520 van Leyden, ca. 1520-1530 van Luttervelt, 1958 van Mander, 1604 van Meckenem, 15th century van Oestvoren, 1413 van Oostsanen, 1517 van Os, 1488 van Tricht, ca. 1492 van Wavere, ca. 1515 Venturi, 1945 Vermeylen, 1939 Verwijs & Verdam, 1885-1929 Verwijs, 1860 Verwijs, 1871 Vetter, 1955 Veurman & Bax, 1944 Vinken & Schlüter, 2000 Vinken, 1958 Visscher, 1614 von der Vogelweide, ca. 12-13th century von Eschenbach, ca. 1200-1210 von Fallersleben, 1855 von Fallersleben, 1968 von Kaysersberg, 1510 von Kaysersberg, 1511 von Seidlitz, 1935 Vostre, 1502 Wagner, 1845 Walker, 1975 Welsford, 1935 Werner, 1960 Wertheim Aymès, 1957 Wescher, 1946 Wieck, 1988 Wierix, ca. 1568 Wierix, ca. 1604 Wilhelm, 1990 Willshire, 1883 Winkel, 1922 Winkler, 1924 Winkler, 1951 Winternitz, 1967 Woordenboek der Nederlandsche Taal II, 1882 Woordenboek der Nederlandsche Taal III, 1912 Woordenboek der Nederlandsche Taal IV, 1916 Workshop of Orcagna, 15th-16th century Workshop of Taddeo Gaddi, 14th century Yamey, 1989 Zupnick, 1968 Refers To (Title) Contains symbolic references TextualVisual Types of Interpretation Conception of Information According to Furner (2004) Utterances Situations Thoughts Informativeness Relevance (Iconographical) Relevance (Iconological) Communication Layers of meaning According to van Straten (1994) Views of reality According to Popper (1972, 1979) & Gnoli (2018) Levels of knowledgeAccording to Nanetti (2018) If you are human, leave this field blank. This form is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Filter Entries Show All Δ 87 interpretations found. #62 Couple in a pink tent with clothes on shore from An Allegory of Intemperance His symbolism has received many interpretations including psychoanalytic explanations for the erotic images. Yet a simpler and perhaps more reliable approach to understanding Bosch’s imagery is offered by Sebastian Brant’s Das Narrenschiff (Ship of Fools) [Bax, 1948, 199]. (p.18) Rossiter, 1973 Bosch and Brant: Images of Folly #81 Couple in a pink tent with clothes on shore from An Allegory of Intemperance Surmounted by the sign of a cleft hoof, the pink tent represents a house of drink and lust. The fragile decoration tracing the edges of the roof, the square hole in the roof and absence of a door suggest the impermanence of the dwelling in which the couple carelessly celebrates. Brant describes a similar abandonment to pleasure in Of the Power of Fools [Winkler, 1951, 13; Brant, 1962, 169]. (p.23) Rossiter, 1973 Bosch and Brant: Images of Folly #82 Couple in a pink tent with clothes on shore from An Allegory of Intemperance The tent of mirth and the train of clothes leading up to it allude to a seduction. (p.23) Rossiter, 1973 Bosch and Brant: Images of Folly #84 Couple in a pink tent with clothes on shore from An Allegory of Intemperance Bosch implies a connection between drinking and love-making in the tent o mirth through the erotic symbol of a jug upon the table. Framed by the door, the whispering couple stands alone in the tent’s dim interior, involved in a private tête-à-tête. Light fails to pierce the black-reddish depths of the murky space behind the lovers, enhancing the sense of forbidden mystery within. Yet the couple does not appear to enjoy their moment of secret passion. The onslaught bold and blind remains more blind than bold, for the lovers appear sightless, their eyes blurred by shadow. Though the woman makes a small gesture towards the man (or towards the cup of wine) , she turns her face away and avoids looking at him. (p.23) Rossiter, 1973 Bosch and Brant: Images of Folly #104 Couple in a pink tent with clothes on shore from An Allegory of Intemperance … worldly vice of luxury…show the combination of lust and indulgence known among the Seven Sins as luxuria. We can easily compare the scene of Luxuria from the Seven Deadly Sins panel, which displays a similar combination of rich costume, taste, and eros [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510]. (p.630) Silver, 2001 God in the Details: Bosch and Judgment(s) #106 Boat with ten people onboard from Ship of Fools … worldly vice of luxury…show the combination of lust and indulgence known among the Seven Sins as luxuria. We can easily compare the scene of Luxuria from the Seven Deadly Sins panel [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510], which displays a similar combination of rich costume, taste, and eros…we find there some of the same costly foodstuffs (especially cherries and roast fowl) and wine flasks, as well as a fool in his standard costume. (p.630) Silver, 2001 God in the Details: Bosch and Judgment(s) #107 Nun playing the lute from Ship of Fools Music (often an emblem of wasteful indulgence in Bosch, especially in the Hell wing of The Garden of Earthly Delights triptych) is common to both worlds of luxury, but the Prado panel contains both harp and recorder, while the Paris panel has only a lute. (p.630) Silver, 2001 God in the Details: Bosch and Judgment(s) #108 Nun playing the lute from Ship of Fools Ironically, these instruments tend to occur in images with angelic musicians in 15th-century Flemish paintings, presumably as prestige instruments associated with (heavenly) court life, in contrast to the more vulgar bagpipes and other peasant instruments. [Winternitz, 1967, 66-85, 129-149; Hammerstein, 1962; Brant, 1944, 186.] (p.647, note 19) Silver, 2001 God in the Details: Bosch and Judgment(s) #112 Boat with ten people onboard from Ship of Fools …the Paris-New Haven wing embodies a deadly sin here, luxury, both of gourmandise (rather than the sin of gluttony, with its own segment on the circle of sins) and of sexuality (note that the scene of the punishment for luxury in the Hell roundel of the Prado sins consists of a fornicating couple in bed with demons[Bosch, ca. 1505-1510, “The Seven Deadly Sins and the Four Last Things”]). (p.630) Silver, 2001 God in the Details: Bosch and Judgment(s) #116 Couple in a pink tent with clothes on shore from An Allegory of Intemperance …unchaste love, as represented by the couple in the tent. This couple could be regarded as the core from which all sins derive, hence this wing could aptly be titled Luxuria…(pp.31-32) Hartau, 2005 (Bosch and the Jews) Bosch and the Jews #133 Table with beaker and cherries from Ship of Fools On the board between them, which does duty for a table, is a dish of cheeries (symbol of sensual pleasure). (p. 31) Delevoy, 1960 Bosch #134 Nun playing the lute from Ship of Fools Surrounded by a shipload of grotesque characters plainly the worse for drink, they sit face to face, singing lustily to the sound of a lute (which at the time had erotic associations). (p. 31) Delevoy, 1960 Bosch #166 Tree mast with owl from Ship of Fools De plaats, die de laatste auteur uit Colijn van Rijssele’s Spiegel der Minnen verklaart: „nu craectse haesnoten Juyst met haer teenen In een cleen bosselken [de Tollenaere, 1941, 128], komt overeen met het gezegde uit het toneelstuk van Leander ende Hero: „In prieelen en bosschen de rijpe haselnoten metten teenen kraecken [Kalff, 1907, 214]. Een voorbeeld van „die nootkens craken vindt men in Brands:900 Brands, 1921, 900]. Het bosje waarin op Jeroens Hooiwagen een minnend paar half schuilgaat, lijkt een hazelaarsbosje [Bosch, ca. 1512-1515]. (p. 196, note 74) Bax, 1949 Ontcijfering van Jeroen Bosch #172 Table with beaker and cherries from Ship of Fools Men moet in de kers een zinnebeeld zien van het vrouwelijk geslachtsdeel, dat in geheel Europa vaak met vruchtennamen aangeduid wordt. De vruchten op het schilderij hebben ook dubbelzinnige betekenis, want kersen eten is het minnespel spelen. (p. 193) Bax, 1949 Ontcijfering van Jeroen Bosch #173 Nun playing the lute from Ship of Fools De luit waarop de non tokkelt, steunt deze veronderstelling [het minnespel spelen]. Dit instrument komt in onze 16de-eeuwse taal en beeldende kunst nl. in erotische zin voor. Zo betekende „spelen met der luten hetzelfde als kersen eten [Leuvense bijdragen, 1990, 331] en schilderde Cornelis Metsys vrouwen, die luiten aan een luitensteller brengen [Massys, 16th century] (p. 193) Bax, 1949 Ontcijfering van Jeroen Bosch #176 Table with beaker and cherries from Ship of Fools De twee kersen aan één steel, welke de harpenaar op de naar een compositie van Bosch vervaardigde gravure van die blau schuyte in zijn hand houdt [van der Heyden, 1559], hebben waarschijnlijk dezelfde functie als de vruchten op het paneeltje. (p. 193) Bax, 1949 Ontcijfering van Jeroen Bosch #193 Nun and monk from Ship of Fools De non, die op het schilderij dezen monnik tot partner dient, wordt ook in het gedicht beschreven. Zij is één… Voert vanden gueden vroukijns fijn, Die gaern bi die guede ghesellen sijn, Ende die Venus dwinghet, die goddinne, Ende garen draghen verholen minne, Ist abdisse ofte nonne [Verwijs, 1871, 98:vs. 125-129] (p. 147) Enklaar, 1933 De Blaue Schult #210 Nun and monk from Ship of Fools De non, die op het schilderij dezen monnik tot partner dient, wordt ook in het gedicht beschreven. Zij is één… Voert vanden gueden vroukijns fijn, Die gaern bi die guede ghesellen sijn, Ende die Venus dwinghet, die goddinne, Ende garen draghen verholen minne, Ist abdisse ofte nonne [Verwijs, 1871, 98:vs. 125-129] (p. 68) Enklaar, 1937 Varende Luyden. Studiën over de middeleeuwsche groepen van onmaatschappelijken in de Nederlanden. #254 Man on a barrel with five skinny men in the waters from An Allegory of Intemperance …more likely a fragment of a representation of two of the Deadly Sins, Lust and Intemperance, and thinks it might have belonged to a painting cited in the inventory of the collection of Marghareta Boge in Antwerp in 1574 [Baldass, 1943, 22, 235; Baldass, 1959, 26, 229; de Tolnay, 1937, 90, no. 9; Bosch, ca. 1505-1510, “The Seven Deadly Sins and the Four Last Things”] (p.207) Detroit Institute Arts, 1960 Flanders in the fifteenth century: Art and civilization #255 Couple in a pink tent with clothes on shore from An Allegory of Intemperance …more likely a fragment of a representation of two of the Deadly Sins, Lust and Intemperance, and thinks it might have belonged to a painting cited in the inventory of the collection of Marghareta Boge in Antwerp in 1574 [Baldass, 1943, 22, 235; Baldass, 1959, 26, 229; de Tolnay, 1937, 90, no. 9; Bosch, ca. 1505-1510, “The Seven Deadly Sins and the Four Last Things”] (p.207) Detroit Institute Arts, 1960 Flanders in the fifteenth century: Art and civilization #280 Old tavern from The Pedlar Dans I’encadrement de la porte, Scène décevante de frivolité, un soldat de passage, un traînard isolé lutine une pauvre servante de I’Auberge du Cygne. Par le monde entier, l’Enfant a vu l’horrible séduction, I’innocence toujours condamnée. Si au cours de ses voyages pédestres il est devenu poète et philosophe, Bosch nous montre qu’il n’y a pas perdu les sentiments qui se groupent entre et avec la pitié et la charité. Peut-être le soudard aura-t-il moins de scrupules parce que la maison est pauvre, ou qu’elle est de celles où depuis Iongtemps l’innocence est inconnue. Le toit est défoncé, les carreaux cassés, un volet détaché de ses gonds. Un homme, qui connaît le désordre de la place, s’est à peine éloigné pour satisfaire un besoin naturel. A deux pas de la porte, une truie et ses porcelets vident une auge, ‘ deux poules picorent sur un tas d’ordures. (p. 5) de Boschère, 1947 Jérôme Bosch #290 Old tavern with pigs and rooster from The Pedlar The profligacy and lust featured on the left were traits especially associated to youth. (p. 191) Fischer, 2016 Jheronimus Bosch #294 Table with beaker and cherries from Ship of Fools A pewter beaker and a plate of cherries, symbols of carnal lust [Vandenbroeck, 1989, 162f], stand between them (the friar and nun) on a plank that projects out over the side of the boat like a springboard. (p. 191). Fischer, 2016 Jheronimus Bosch #301 Barrel hanging on boat from Ship of Fools …a barrel in the boat, a fish dangling from the right branch and a jug hanging upside down at the end of a long branch rising diagonally upwards on the left: a symbol of Lust. (p. 191) Fischer, 2016 Jheronimus Bosch #302 Fish hanging on tree branch from Ship of Fools …a barrel in the boat, a fish dangling from the right branch and a jug hanging upside down at the end of a long branch rising diagonally upwards on the left: a symbol of Lust. (p. 191) Fischer, 2016 Jheronimus Bosch #303 Stick with upturned jug from Ship of Fools …a barrel in the boat, a fish dangling from the right branch and a jug hanging upside down at the end of a long branch rising diagonally upwards on the left: a symbol of Lust. (pp. 191-192) Fischer, 2016 Jheronimus Bosch #305 Couple in a pink tent with clothes on shore from An Allegory of Intemperance The foreground scene at the bottom of the panel treats the theme of Lust in a manner similar to that of the exemplum in The Seven Deadly Sins and the Four Last Things. On the bank near the water a man and woman, whose style of dress suggests that they belong to the middle classes, have withdrawn into a furnished, pale red tent for a tête-à-tête. On the ground in front of the tent entrance are wooden clogs, a hat in the Burgundian style on top of a belt, and a section of trumpet. Further items of clothing, probably belonging to the swimmers, are draped over the withered half of an otherwise leafy tree and scattered on the ground nearby. (p. 192) Fischer, 2016 Jheronimus Bosch #306 Stick with upturned jug from Ship of Fools Here, too, a jug is hooked upside down over a branch. The association of drinking, eating, music-making and lust is one we have already encountered in the Garden of Earthly Delights [Bosch, ca. 1490-1500]. Here, as there, flourishing nature becomes a symbol of the uncurbed human instincts that seek only sensual pleasure. (p. 192) Fischer, 2016 Jheronimus Bosch #312 Old tavern with pigs and rooster from The Pedlar The left exterior shutter shows the life of excess, and above all lechery, associated with youth… (p. 192) Fischer, 2016 Jheronimus Bosch #317 Man on a barrel with five skinny men in the waters from An Allegory of Intemperance Various material analyses have proved that this small oak panel, depicting allegories of the deadly sins of Gluttony (gula) and Lust (luxuria) (p. 256) Fischer, 2016 Jheronimus Bosch #318 Couple in a pink tent with clothes on shore from An Allegory of Intemperance Various material analyses have proved that this small oak panel, depicting allegories of the deadly sins of Gluttony (gula) and Lust (luxuria) (p. 256) Fischer, 2016 Jheronimus Bosch #355 Boat with ten people onboard from Ship of Fools Two traditions are of importance in interpreting the merrymakers in the boat in particular. First of all, the branches, as well as the cherries on the plank that serves as a makeshift table, clearly show that these people have set out on a pleasure trip. Especially in the spring, highborn youngsters amused themselves by flirting and making music while sailing around in boats decorated with foliage. This happened in real life, but it was also portrayed in numerous book of hours as illustrations of the month of May. Those depictions, however, invariably show elegantly dressed boys and girls, whose polished manners cannot be compared with the debauched doings of Bosch’s figures. Merrymaking monks and nuns never appear in such scenes [Bax, 1949, 194; de Bruyn, 2001, 80-83; Silver, 2006, 243-252; Ilsink et al., 2016, 212] yet they are part of the other tradition from which this painting seems to derive. Revellers in boats or barges who flout the norms and values of society are known from countless sixteenth-century poems, prints and religious processions. Again and again, social norms were ridiculed by displays of dissolute behaviour, by showing how not to do it, by acting out the topsy-turvy world. For those receptive to the message, it was immediately clear where such behaviour would finally lead – to perdition [Pleij, 1979; Lammertse & van der Coelen, 2015, 62]. (p. 298) Lammertse, 2017 Hieronymus Bosch: The pilgrimage of life triptych #361 Boat with ten people onboard from Ship of Fools Whereas the left wing seems to depict mainly the sins of gluttony (gula) and lust (luxuria)… (p. 298) Lammertse, 2017 Hieronymus Bosch: The pilgrimage of life triptych #363 Man on a barrel with five skinny men in the waters from An Allegory of Intemperance “Whereas the left wing seems to depict mainly the sins of gluttony (gula) and lust (luxuria)… (p. 298)” Lammertse, 2017 Hieronymus Bosch: The pilgrimage of life triptych #369 Couple in a pink tent with clothes on shore from An Allegory of Intemperance “Whereas the left wing seems to depict mainly the sins of gluttony (gula) and lust (luxuria)… (p. 298)” Lammertse, 2017 Hieronymus Bosch: The pilgrimage of life triptych #399 Old tavern from The Pedlar A soldier who has leaned his over long lance against the wall fondles a woman in the doorway. (p.56) Friedländer, 1927 Die Altniederländische Malerei, 5 #428 Man and woman at doorway of tavern from The Pedlar Dat de kroeg op het schilderij een verdacht huis is, onthult niet alleen de juffrouw – een kellnerin? —, die in de deur door een landsknecht geknuffeld wordt [Langendijk, 1715, vs. 8; Hildebrand, 1911, 333]… Dat een landsknecht het er eens van nam, zijn speer op zij zette, om een juffer in de bouten te vatten, zal ook in een gewone herberg geen uitzondering geweest zijn. (p. 80-82) Enklaar, 1940 Uit Uilenspiegel’s kring #429 Hanging birdcage from The Pedlar Maar het suspecte karakter van de gelegenheid wordt buiten eiken twijfel gesteld door den mand met den vogel, die naast de deur hangt. Hetzelfde teeken ziet men ook op de schilderijen van Hemessen te Karlsruhe en te Berlijn [Friedländer, 1935, 81; van Hemessen, ca. 1540; Monogrammist, ca. 1530]. Het is mogelijk, dat dit ook in het werkelijke leven het teeken is geweest, waarmede dergelijke huizen zich afficheerden, te vergelijken met het groote huisnummer onzer dagen. Maar dan zit er toch zeker een woordspeling in. In Manken van Nieumeghen insinueert de moeye, dat haar nichtje „yewers in een camer ghemuyt si, daer men sulken tijtkens om een grootken speet”, d.w.z. zulke „kippetjes” voor een gering bedrag aan het spit steekt [Leendertz Jr., 1907, 292]. Hetzelfde beeld „ghemuyt” oftewel gekooid gebruikt Heynken de Luyere, in alle gelegenheden van dit slag thuis, als hij op zoek naar een op het breede pad geraakte „nichte, die schoon van aenschijn was ende van leven lichte” [Crul, 1920, 11]… Ook de duiven, waarvan er een rondvliegt en een ander onder den nok van het huis op til zit, bedoelen aan te duiden, dat in de kroeg gelegenheid tot het plegen van ontucht wordt gegeven; duiven op zolder houden, is tot den huidigen dag een euphemisme voor: een publiek huis houden [Woordenboek der Nederlandsche Taal III, 1912, col. 3561; Harrebomée, 1858, 159] (p. 82) Enklaar, 1940 Uit Uilenspiegel’s kring #431 Rooster from The Pedlar Wat in het gedicht uitgedrukt wordt door het beeld van den roodgekamden haan, verbeeldt ook wel het dier op het schilderij, dat daar bovenop den mesthoop prijkt [Bisschop & Verwijs, 1870, 173]. (p. 83) Enklaar, 1940 Uit Uilenspiegel’s kring #448 Nun and monk from Ship of Fools The monk and one of the nuns are singing lustily, the latter accompanying herself on a lute; they resemble the amorous couples depicted in medieval love gardens, who make music as a prelude to making love. (p. 41) Gibson, 1973 Hieronymus Bosch #449 Table with beaker and cherries from Ship of Fools The allusion to the sin of Lust is reinforced by other details drawn from the traditional Garden of Love – the plate of cherries and the metal wine jug suspended over the side of the boat – which Bosch had employed for the same sin in the Prado Tabletop [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510]. (p. 41) Gibson, 1973 Hieronymus Bosch #450 Barrel hanging on boat from Ship of Fools The allusion to the sin of Lust is reinforced by other details drawn from the traditional Garden of Love – the plate of cherries and the metal wine jug suspended over the side of the boat – which Bosch had employed for the same sin in the Prado Tabletop [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510]. (p. 41) Gibson, 1973 Hieronymus Bosch #458 Man on a barrel with five skinny men in the waters from An Allegory of Intemperance The intimate association between Gluttony and Lust in the medieval moral system was expressed by Bosch… (p. 44) Gibson, 1973 Hieronymus Bosch #460 Man on a barrel with five skinny men in the waters from An Allegory of Intemperance …on the right, by a pair of lovers in a tent, another motif reminiscent of the Lust scene in the Prado Tabletop [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510, “The Seven Deadly Sins and the Four Last Things”]. That they should be engaged in drinking wine is entirely appropriate: Sine Cerere et Liberto friget Venue (Without Ceres and Bacchus, Venus freezes); this tag from Terence was well known to the Middle Ages, and that Gluttony and Drunkenness lead to Lust was a lesson that the moralizers never tired of driving home to their audiences. (p. 46) Gibson, 1973 Hieronymus Bosch #495 Nun and monk from Ship of Fools The monk and one of the nuns are singing lustily, the latter accompanying herself on a lute; they resemble the amorous couples depicted in medieval love gardens, who make music as a prelude to making love. (p. 30) Bosing, 1987 Hieronymus Bosch c.1450-1516 #496 Table with beaker and cherries from Ship of Fools The allusion to the sin of Lust is reinforced by other details drawn from the traditional Garden of Love – the plate of cherries and the metal wine jug suspended over the side of the boat – which Bosch had employed for the same sin in the Prado Tabletop [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510]. (p. 30) Bosing, 1987 Hieronymus Bosch c.1450-1516 #497 Barrel hanging on boat from Ship of Fools The allusion to the sin of Lust is reinforced by other details drawn from the traditional Garden of Love – the plate of cherries and the metal wine jug suspended over the side of the boat – which Bosch had employed for the same sin in the Prado Tabletop [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510, “The Seven Deadly Sins and the Four Last Things”]. (p. 30) Bosing, 1987 Hieronymus Bosch c.1450-1516 #504 Couple in a pink tent with clothes on shore from An Allegory of Intemperance The intimate association between Gluttony and Lust in the medieval moral system was expressed by Bosch… (p. 44) Gibson, 1973 Hieronymus Bosch #505 Man on a barrel with five skinny men in the waters from An Allegory of Intemperance The intimate association between Gluttony and Lust in the medieval moral system was expressed by Bosch… (p. 32) Bosing, 1987 Hieronymus Bosch c.1450-1516 #506 Couple in a pink tent with clothes on shore from An Allegory of Intemperance The intimate association between Gluttony and Lust in the medieval moral system was expressed by Bosch… (p. 32) Bosing, 1987 Hieronymus Bosch c.1450-1516 #508 Man on a barrel with five skinny men in the waters from An Allegory of Intemperance …on the right, by a pair of lovers in a tent, another motif reminiscent of the Lust scene in the Prado Tabletop [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510, “The Seven Deadly Sins and the Four Last Things”]. That they should be engaged in drinking wine is entirely appropriate: Sine Cerere et Liberto friget Venue (Without Ceres and Bacchus, Venus freezes); this tag from Terene was well known to the Middle Ages, and that Gluttony and Drunkenness lead to Lust was a lesson that the moralizers never tired of driving home to their audiences. (p. 32) Bosing, 1987 Hieronymus Bosch c.1450-1516 #530 Boat with ten people onboard from Ship of Fools That even this highly eccentric-seeming Ship of Fools has to do with some activity connected with either the deadly sins or the seasons is suggested by an exploration of the new iconography of the Months introduced at the end of the fourteenth century. As Pächt shows, depictions of the activities of each month had been done mostly in the form of wall paintings until the fifteenth century, when they began to appear in manuscript miniatures [Pächt, 1948]. There are Books of Hours from the time when Bosch began his career in which, as Cuttler found, the month of May was generally illustrated with a boating party [Cuttler, 1969]. From the same period there are also pictures of groups of monks in boats, and since the devils always busy themselves with such lusty companies, these would appear to be meant as disreputable. It is a safe assumption that, in Bosch’s time, such an association of boat trips with sinful monks was widespread. Nevertheless much remains to be explained here, especially since in another source one finds a monk and nun cooperating (or worse) in some blasphemous action. In which case the cake suspended from above would be the host and the board between the two an altar table set with chalice and paten. Yet there are others in the picture, and their only message seems to be that “where ignorance is bliss, ‘Tis folly to be wise.” (p. 66) Linfert, 1989 Hieronymus Bosch #544 Man on a barrel with five skinny men in the waters from An Allegory of Intemperance … was first published by Tolnay [de Tolnay, 1937], who suggested it might depict an episode concerning the Prodigal Son… Adhémar… believed it to have been a whole symbolising May or Spring) [Adhémar, 1962; Bosch, ca. 1475-1500, “La Nef des fous (The Ship of Fools)”]… Baldass believed it, instead, to be part of a panel illustrating the Deadly Sins [Baldass, 1959]. Bax (1949) viewed it as the summer feast of a merry party, and interpreted the various objects as symbols of forbidden love. The fragment depicts in a lively style akin to that of The Ship of Fools [Bosch, ca. 1475-1500, “La Nef des fous (The Ship of Fools)”] and with a delightful lightness of touch, Lust (a couple of lovers under a tent) and Gluttony, in the shape of a sort of Flemish Silenus [Seymour, 1961] bestriding a floating cask from which wine spills: this figure inspired the ‘Carnival’ of Bruegel’s Carnival and Lent in Vienna [Bruegel, 1559, “The Fight between Carnival and Lent”]. (p. 93) Cinotti, 1966 The complete paintings of Bosch #545 Couple in a pink tent with clothes on shore from An Allegory of Intemperance … was first published by Tolnay [de Tolnay, 1937], who suggested it might depict an episode concerning the Prodigal Son… Adhémar… believed it to have been a whole symbolising May or Spring) [Adhémar, 1962; Bosch, ca. 1475-1500]… Baldass believed it, instead, to be part of a panel illustrating the Deadly Sins [Baldass, 1959]. Bax (1949) viewed it as the summer feast of a merry party, and interpreted the various objects as symbols of forbidden love. The fragment depicts in a lively style akin to that of The Ship of Fools [Bosch, ca. 1475-1500] and with a delightful lightness of touch, Lust (a couple of lovers under a tent) and Gluttony, in the shape of a sort of Flemish Silenus [Seymour, 1961] bestriding a floating cask from which wine spills: this figure inspired the ‘Carnival’ of Bruegel’s Carnival and Lent in Vienna [Bruegel, 1559 (The Fight between Carnival and Lent)]. (p. 93) Cinotti, 1966 The complete paintings of Bosch #557 Boat with ten people onboard from Ship of Fools Bosch did not just take influences from Leonardo. He also gave some back. There is a good likelihood that the Italian artist based his undated drawing at Windsor called Allegory with a Wolf and Eagle [da Vinci, ca. 1591-1624] on an early version of Bosch’s frequently depicted Ship of Fools. In the painting at the Louvre, which is the best known best example of Bosch’s depictions of the Ship of Fools, the gluttonous and lustful figures ride on a boat which has a tree for a mast. Leonardo’s wolflike creature, which represent humanity;s animal side, rides on a similar boat. Leonardo’s version of the scene is more optimistic than Bosch’s, however. Bosch’s fools are determinedly unaware, but Leonardo’s animal steers its way by an eagle, a symbol of the higher self. (p. 79) Harris, 1995 The secret heresy of Hieronymus Bosch #566 Old tavern from The Pedlar The inn which he [the peddler] finds so tempting is obviously a place of sin and corruption. Its swan signboard, its pigeons in the loft, its jug, and its women all show that it is a house of prostitution. It also a place of drunkenness and intoxication. Symbols of drink include the leaking barrel and the man who urinates at the side of the wall. Bosch’s inn can be interpreted as a conventional Christian image of temptation, but it corresponds even more closely with a metaphor in the Manichean-related Hymn of the Pearl. In this poem, the Saviour who has come to rescue the fallen soul goes to stay in a similar inn. Symbolically, this is a temporary dwelling, which represents the earth [Jonas, 1963, 55f.]. Like the tavern/brothel in the painting at Rotterdam, it is a place where corruption and drunkenness are rife. (pp. 163-164) Harris, 1995 The secret heresy of Hieronymus Bosch #571 Left leg with bandage from The Pedlar The wanderer’s bandaged leg left leg is also significant from the Cathar point of view. It indicates that he is wounded…. the wound means that he is subject to sin, and its location on the left foot or leg identifies his sin as lust. The wayfarer is not shown as undeemably wicked, however. (p. 165) Harris, 1995 The secret heresy of Hieronymus Bosch #613 Hanging hoof amulet and white string from coat from The Pedlar At the very center of the tondo the eye is caught by a pig’s trotter hanging from the man’s coat. The clover hoof occurs frequently in Bosch as a symbol of base urge and lusts. Up to now the man has kept it hidden in his bosom, but now, in this decisive hour of his life, what he has had a heart comes to light. To make the meaning of the crux of his meditational picture as clear as possible, Bosch has indicated the exact moment in time when the spiritual event occurs. From the front opening of the man’s coat, in a strongly accented vertical, hanged a white string. The pig’s foot was tied to this string. But as the repentant Prodigal hunches forward to jerk himself free once and for all from his corrupt ways, the tie to the “swine within” breaks and he drops the emblem of evil pursuits – which jauntily continue in the open doorway across the road, where the soldier and pot girl meet… The pig’s trotter is the devil’s cloven hoof, lurking behind the story Bosch tells. (pp. 260-265) Fraenger, 1999 Hieronymus Bosch #706 Rooster from The Pedlar The rooster which occurs near the inn in Bosch’s painting [Philip, 1958, 6: note 14] is a symbol of lust and unchastity and is also connected with the procuring activities of the peddler. The rooster originally signified fertility and was therefore an attribute of the god Mercury. In the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries the cock frequently appears on the caps of fools in representations in which the fool is the entertainer and procurer. Cf., for instance, the fool as the maître de plaisir in the woodcut by Cornelis Teunissen, repr. in Hampe [Anthonisz, 1541]. There are innumerable examples of fools, prostitutes, procures, go-betweens and match-makers with the rooster [Bax, 1949]. (p. 69:note 146) Philip, 1958 The Peddler by Hieronymus Bosch, a study in detectio #707 Pigs from The Pedlar The swine, the counterparts of the rooster in Bosch’s representation [Philip, 1958, 4:note 10]), also point to unchastity and prostitution when seen in the story-telling context of the painting [Seligmann, 1953, 101; Bax, 1949, 50, 99, 223]. (p. 69:note 146) Philip, 1958 The Peddler by Hieronymus Bosch, a study in detectio #730 Boat with ten people onboard from Ship of Fools Der Einfluß Brants auf Bosch ist im satirischen Ton spürbar, in der närrischen Freude dieser weltlichen und geistlichen Mai-Kahnfahrer… «Avaritia» und «Luxuria» sind bei Bosch wie bei Brant die zwei Hauptlaster, die den Ordo verkehren [Bohnert, 1985]. Eine wichtige Anregung konnte auch von Badius’ «Narrenschiff» mit weiblichen Närrinnen ausgegangen sein. (p. 168) Hartau, 2002 “Narrenschiffe” um 1500 #747 Boat with ten people onboard from Ship of Fools …Ship of Fools is a companion piece to the Miser ; it could have covered two additional sins, gluttony and lust [Benesch, 1957, 33f.; Baldass, 1943, 235; Baldass, 1968, 621; Gerlach, 1979, 14; Morganstern, 1982, 41:note 41-42]. (p. 38) Morganstern, 1982 The Pawns in Bosch’s” Death and the Miser” #748 Man on a barrel with five skinny men in the waters from An Allegory of Intemperance …Ship of Fools is a companion piece to the Miser; it could have covered two additional sins, gluttony and lust [Benesch, 1957, 33f.; Baldass, 1943, 235; Baldass, 1968, 621; Gerlach, 1979, 14; Morganstern, 1982, 41:note 41-42]. (p. 38) Morganstern, 1982 The Pawns in Bosch’s” Death and the Miser” #749 Couple in a pink tent with clothes on shore from An Allegory of Intemperance …Ship of Fools is a companion piece to the Miser ; it could have covered two additional sins, gluttony and lust [Benesch, 1957, 33f.; Baldass, 1943, 235; Baldass, 1968, 621; Gerlach, 1979, 14; Morganstern, 1982, 41:note 41-42]. (p. 38) Morganstern, 1982 The Pawns in Bosch’s” Death and the Miser” #750 Boat with ten people onboard from Ship of Fools Otto Benesch suggested that the Ship of Fools could have been part of a series of the Seven Deadly Sins and signify Gluttony [Benesch, 1957, 33f]. Baldass [Baldass, 1943, 235; Baldass, 1968, 621] has suggested that the Yale panel, represents Lust and Gluttony from a similar series, and this idea has been recently endorsed by Gerlach [Gerlach, 1979, 14]. (p. 41:note 41) Morganstern, 1982 The Pawns in Bosch’s” Death and the Miser” #751 Man on a barrel with five skinny men in the waters from An Allegory of Intemperance Otto Benesch suggested that the Ship of Fools could have been part of a series of the Seven Deadly Sins and signify Gluttony [Benesch, 1957, 33f]. Baldass [Baldass, 1943, 235; Baldass, 1968, 621] has suggested that the Yale panel, represents Lust and Gluttony from a similar series, and this idea has been recently endorsed by Gerlach [Gerlach, 1979, 14]. (p. 41:note 41) Morganstern, 1982 The Pawns in Bosch’s” Death and the Miser” #752 Couple in a pink tent with clothes on shore from An Allegory of Intemperance Otto Benesch suggested that the Ship of Fools could have been part of a series of the Seven Deadly Sins and signify Gluttony [Benesch, 1957, 33f]. Baldass [Baldass, 1943, 235; Baldass, 1968, 621] has suggested that the Yale panel, represents Lust and Gluttony from a similar series, and this idea has been recently endorsed by Gerlach [Gerlach, 1979, 14]. (p. 41:note 41) Morganstern, 1982 The Pawns in Bosch’s” Death and the Miser” #763 Man on a barrel with five skinny men in the waters from An Allegory of Intemperance The panels appear to depict allegories of three of the Seven Deadly Sins [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510]. Both the Louvre and the Yale paintings have often been associated with Gluttony and Lust [Morganstern, 1984, 300:note 30; Benesch, 1957, 33-34; Adhémar, 1962, 28-29; de Mirimonde, 1971, 34-35; Cuttler, 1969, 274-275], and the reconstruction of these panels strengthens that association. (p. 300) Morganstern, 1984 The Rest of Bosch’s Ship of Fools #764 Couple in a pink tent with clothes on shore from An Allegory of Intemperance The panels appear to depict allegories of three of the Seven Deadly Sins [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510]. Both the Louvre and the Yale paintings have often been associated with Gluttony and Lust [Morganstern, 1984, 300:note 30; Benesch, 1957, 33-34; Adhémar, 1962, 28-29; de Mirimonde, 1971, 34-35; Cuttler, 1969, 274-275], and the reconstruction of these panels strengthens that association. (p. 300) Morganstern, 1984 The Rest of Bosch’s Ship of Fools #765 Boat with ten people onboard from Ship of Fools The panels appear to depict allegories of three of the Seven Deadly Sins [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510]. Both the Louvre and the Yale paintings have often been associated with Gluttony and Lust [Morganstern, 1984, 300:note 30; Benesch, 1957, 33-34; Adhémar, 1962, 28-29; de Mirimonde, 1971, 34-35; Cuttler, 1969, 274-275], and the reconstruction of these panels strengthens that association. (p. 300) Morganstern, 1984 The Rest of Bosch’s Ship of Fools #766 Boat with ten people onboard from Ship of Fools Otto Benesch suggested that the Ship of Fools could have been part of a series of the Seven Deadly Sins and signify Gluttony [Benesch, 1957, 33-34]. His suggestion was supported by Adhémar’s analysis of the theme [Adhémar, 1962, 28-29], and has been echoed recently by A. P. de Mirimonde [Mirimonde, 1971, 34-35]. Cuttler interpreted the Ship of Fools as a moralizing satire on Gluttony, with Lust possibly a subtheme [Cuttler, 1969, 274-275]. (p. 300:note 30) Morganstern, 1984 The Rest of Bosch’s Ship of Fools #769 Boat with ten people onboard from Ship of Fools The ship with its merrymakers remains the principal motif, but its theme is amplified by the glutton astride a barrel who seems to herald the vessel’s approach to those ashore, some of whom have already abandoned their clothing and taken to the water. Although the situation of the ship’s occupants seems less precarious when now seen close to land, the presence of the knight in the water adds a new threat to their security. In this panel, Bosch represents Gluttony and Lust as dangerous and also foolish, for an indifferent jester presides over all. That he chose to combine the two sins in one panel need not surprise us. Gregory the Great had put Gluttony and Lust at the end of his list of the Seven Cardinal Sins and labeled them carnal [Bloomfield, 1952, 72]. His example was followed by a frequent association of them in subsequent medieval commentary [Bloomfield, 1952, 73, 89, 140, 174f, 197, 215], and Bosch included allusions to gluttony in his illustration of Lust in the Prado Tabletop [Morganstern, 1984, 301:note 34; Baldass, 1968; Bosch, ca. 1505-1510]. (pp. 300-301) Morganstern, 1984 The Rest of Bosch’s Ship of Fools #775 Couple in a pink tent with clothes on shore from An Allegory of Intemperance Das “Gula”-Fragment schildert Szenen von Lebenslust und Zügellosigkeit. (p. 182) Hartau (Suche nach Glück bei nahem Untergang), 2001 Suche nach Glück bei nahem Untergang #798 Hanging hoof amulet and white string from coat from The Pedlar The hoof appears to be associated with gluttony and lust – sins that were known to prosper in public houses. Within Bosch’s own oeuvre, hooves are shown in contexts that seem to establish this association. A hoof is portrayed on a banner flying above a tent that serves as a tavern and brothel in the fragment of a painting at Yale, Allegory of Gluttony and Lust [Bosch, ca. 1495–1500; de Tolnay, 1966, 94]. Another hoof is shown clutched in the greedy hand of the jug-holding glutton in the Seven Deadly Sins tabletop [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510; de Tolnay, 1966, 66]. The Rotterdam poor man’s hoof would thus suggest that he is guilty of similar carnal indulgences. (pp. 94-95) Tuttle, 1981 Bosch’s Image of Poverty #805 Boat with ten people onboard from Ship of Fools …lively nudes (and clothed figures) indulging their appetites for food and luxury with the implication of sex) also appear in a divided wing, shared by the Ship of Fools (Musee du Louvre, Paris) and Allegory of Gluttony (Yale University Art Gallery, New Haven) [Bosch, ca. 1495–1500] from a dismembered triptych [Morganstern, 1984, 295-302]. (p. 28) Silver, 2006 Hieronymus Bosch #806 Couple in a pink tent with clothes on shore from An Allegory of Intemperance …lively nudes (and clothed figures) indulging their appetites for food and luxury with the implication of sex) also appear in a divided wing, shared by the Ship of Fools (Musee du Louvre, Paris) [Bosch, ca. 1475-1500] and Allegory of Gluttony (Yale University Art Gallery, New Haven) from a dismembered triptych [Morganstern, 1984, 295-302]. (p. 28) Silver, 2006 Hieronymus Bosch #807 Man on a barrel with five skinny men in the waters from An Allegory of Intemperance …lively nudes (and clothed figures) indulging their appetites for food and luxury with the implication of sex) also appear in a divided wing, shared by the Ship of Fools (Musee du Louvre, Paris) [Bosch, ca. 1475-1500] and Allegory of Gluttony (Yale University Art Gallery, New Haven) from a dismembered triptych [Morganstern, 1984, 295-302]. (p. 28) Silver, 2006 Hieronymus Bosch #811 Man on a barrel with five skinny men in the waters from An Allegory of Intemperance … the Death and the Usurer, unambiguously evokes the late medieval Ars moriendi (Art of Dying [Well) [van Os, 1488] by placing a skeletal figure of Death at the door while an angel and a demon contend for the soul of the expiring old man. In the Prado tabletop of the Seven Deadly Sins [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510], luxuria not only is labeled clearly on the panel but also appears among the other deadly sins, enframed by the Four Last Things: Death (echoing the Washington Usurer panel), Last Judgment, Heaven, and Hell. (p. 29) Silver, 2006 Hieronymus Bosch #812 Boat with ten people onboard from Ship of Fools Certainly images of courtly love bowers figure prominently within calendar page illustrations, particularly for the lusty spring months of April and May. Half a century after Bosch, Pieter Bruegel’s drawing design for a print of Spring [Bruegel, 1565 (Der Frühling)] still features not only the preparation of a formal garden under a matron’s careful supervision in the foreground but also, at its vanishing point, a love bower, where feasting, drinking, and music as well as boating provide conducive conditions for lovemaking. [Silver, 2006, 400:note 37; van der Heyden, 1570; Bening, ca. 1515; Orenstein, 2001, 236-238: no. 105-106; Wieck, 1988, 45-54]… Once more, it should be recalled that these are precisely the kinds of activities condemned elsewhere by Bosch as the sin of luxuria in his Prado table tabletop [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510] and in his wing panel of the Ship of Fools… Indeed, such activities mark gardens of love (sometimes with added ascetic figures to be discovered) in later Flemish and Dutch painting, from Pieter Pourbus, Allegory of True Love [Pourbus, c. 1547] to a nascent seventeenth-century genre of “merry companies,’ where well-dressed young aristocrats feast and flirt in outdoor garden settings [Silver, 2006, 400:note 38; Huvenne, 1979; Nevitt, 2003, 21-98; de Bruyn, 1604; de Bruyn, 1601; Hellerstedt, 1986, 42-44, no. 16; Renger, 1976, 190-203; Nichols, 1992, 32-42]. (pp. 52-53) Silver, 2006 Hieronymus Bosch #814 Man on a barrel with five skinny men in the waters from An Allegory of Intemperance Certainly images of courtly love bowers figure prominently within calendar page illustrations, particularly for the lusty spring months of April and May. Half a century after Bosch, Pieter Bruegel’s drawing design for a print of Spring [Bruegel, 1565 (Der Frühling)] still features not only the preparation of a formal garden under a matron’s careful supervision in the foreground but also, at its vanishing point, a love bower, where feasting, drinking, and music as well as boating provide conducive conditions for lovemaking. [Silver, 2006, 400:note 37; van der Heyden, 1570; Bening, ca. 1515; Orenstein, 2001, 236-238: no. 105-106; Wieck, 1988, 45-54]… Once more, it should be recalled that these are precisely the kinds of activities condemned elsewhere by Bosch as the sin of luxuria in his Prado table tabletop [Bosch, ca. 1505-1510] and in his wing panel of… an Allegory of Gluttony. Indeed, such activities mark gardens of love (sometimes with added ascetic figures to be discovered) in later Flemish and Dutch painting, from Pieter Pourbus, Allegory of True Love [Pourbus, c. 1547] to a nascent seventeenth-century genre of “merry companies,’ where well-dressed young aristocrats feast and flirt in outdoor garden settings [Silver, 2006, 400:note 38; Huvenne, 1979; Nevitt, 2003, 21-98; de Bruyn, 1604; de Bruyn, 1601; Hellerstedt, 1986, 42-44, no. 16; Renger, 1976, 190-203; Nichols, 1992, 32-42]. (pp. 52-53) Silver, 2006 Hieronymus Bosch #831 Boat with ten people onboard from Ship of Fools …the Paris-New Haven wing presents a consistent enactment of another deadly sin: luxuria, sensuous self-indulgence featuring lust and gluttony in combination. In some respects, this fleshly weakness can be seen as the same kind of product of prosperity that provoked the image of Death and the Usurer [Bosch, ca. 1485-1490]… Bosch exploring such lustful and gluttonous impulses in me central panel of his Garden of Earthly Delights [Bosch, ca. 1490-1500]… its giant fruits and sexually cavorting nudes display a more extreme form of the same behavior as Bosch represents in his Ship of Fools and Allegory of Gluttony wing. (p. 245) Silver, 2006 Hieronymus Bosch #832 Man on a barrel with five skinny men in the waters from An Allegory of Intemperance …the Paris-New Haven wing presents a consistent enactment of another deadly sin: luxuria, sensuous self-indulgence featuring lust and gluttony in combination. In some respects, this fleshly weakness can be seen as the same kind of product of prosperity that provoked the image of Death and the Usurer [Bosch, ca. 1485-1490]… Bosch exploring such lustful and gluttonous impulses in me central panel of his Garden of Earthly Delights [Bosch, ca. 1490-1500]… its giant fruits and sexually cavorting nudes display a more extreme form of the same behavior as Bosch represents in his Ship of Fools and Allegory of Gluttony wing. (p. 245) Silver, 2006 Hieronymus Bosch #833 Couple in a pink tent with clothes on shore from An Allegory of Intemperance …the Paris-New Haven wing presents a consistent enactment of another deadly sin: luxuria, sensuous self-indulgence featuring lust and gluttony in combination. In some respects, this fleshly weakness can be seen as the same kind of product of prosperity that provoked the image of Death and the Usurer [Bosch, ca. 1485-1490]… Bosch exploring such lustful and gluttonous impulses in me central panel of his Garden of Earthly Delights [Bosch, ca. 1490-1500]… its giant fruits and sexually cavorting nudes display a more extreme form of the same behavior as Bosch represents in his Ship of Fools and Allegory of Gluttony wing. (p. 245) Silver, 2006 Hieronymus Bosch #834 Man on his deathbed with a chest from Death and the Miser …the Paris-New Haven wing [Bosch, ca. 1475-1500; Bosch, ca. 1495–1500] presents a consistent enactment of another deadly sin: luxuria, sensuous self-indulgence featuring lust and gluttony in combination. In some respects, this fleshly weakness can be seen as the same kind of product of prosperity that provoked the image of Death and the Usurer. Yet instead of the middle-class money economy of the cities that shapes the Washington panel, this imagery emerges from a court culture, whose private pleasures remained potentially unchecked. (p. 245) Silver, 2006 Hieronymus Bosch #835 Man on a barrel with five skinny men in the waters from An Allegory of Intemperance … the New Haven fragment, we find mere a mixture of both gluttony and lust [Eisler, 1961, 44-48]. (p. 245) Silver, 2006 Hieronymus Bosch #836 Couple in a pink tent with clothes on shore from An Allegory of Intemperance … the New Haven fragment, we find mere a mixture of both gluttony and lust [Eisler, 1961, 44-48]. (p. 245) Silver, 2006 Hieronymus Bosch #879 Catskin on backpack from The Pedlar Eddy de Jongh… noting that “the cat is a well-known symbol of lust and functions as such in numerous erotic scenes” (p. 411:note 31) Silver, 2006 Hieronymus Bosch