Death of a Good LiPo

It’s a sad day today.

We went flying, as usual, at our usual spot. However, I made a fatal mistake regarding where I positioned myself.

Although we were told by Kanesh to not allow the plane to fly behind us, the reality is that weather conditions and pilot competence is not perfect.

As I was flying several rounds around the field, the wind picked up, causing the plane to fly directly over my head. Because I was standing right beside the road lined with trees, this meant that my view of the plane ended up being blocked by the foilage.

Because the Skysurfer had a tendency to roll to the left, I would normally hold the aileron stick to the right to correct this. With the plane being out of direct line of sight (and also because the white plane was flying against white sky), I lost orientation and let go of the stick, causing the Skysurfer to roll over and enter a nosedive at nearly full throttle.

The good news was that the plane missed the trees and flew between openings in the canopy, so that spared us the effort of rushing to get bamboo poles to try to recover the plane.

The bad news was that the plane crashed nose first into Old Holland Road, a proper paved driveway made of rock solid asphalt. This caused the foam at the nose area to disintegrate, crushing the battery inside. It also destroyed the FPV camera (cracked and dislodged the lens from the PCB)

It is truly sad that because of my incompetence, a brand new battery (that is famous in the drone racing scene)was destroyed. On the bright side, no servos were damaged. All the nose needed was a bit more fibre tape and it was back in action with a new battery.

Skysurfer Returns

Over the past few day as I did my revision during recess week, I could not help but think about the plane’s inability to fly on monday. Sure, it was beaten up and the aircraft’s nose has already been compressed inwards, but this could not have contributed to it not being able to fly afterwards. After all, past experience with the plane taught me that all it takes is balancing of the CG before the plane is airworthy again.

To verify that what caused the plane to crash was actually the CG, I went out to old holland road again this morning(1st October 2020). The wind at the time of my arrival was calm, perfect for flying. However, rain was imminent in the distance (buildings started disappearing) and that caused the wind to pick up speed again. I had to act fast and got to work as soon as I could.

The first few flights involved throwing the plane without throttle to see if will glide. Once I was satisfied, real tests began.

The first powered flight was rather shaky. Using a lighter 1500mAh battery meant that the aircraft was tail heavy and I had quite a challenge controlling the plane. Note how in the onboard camera footage, the plane had a tendency to pitch up, and a hard landing caused the camera to be ejected from the canopy (no damage though):

However, it wasn’t long before the 1500mAh battery was expended (somehow, running the motor also caused quite a bit of voltage sag), leaving me with only the heavier 2200mah battery to fly with. That being said, it balanced out the CG perfectly!

I intended to stay for a while longer since the first storm in front of me had blown away (and MSS’s lightning website did not report any lightning activity) but a bigger storm behind me was brewing and I started hearing thunder in the distance (upon checking the MSS website,  massive lightning activity was reported around the Tuas area), so I had to pack up and call it a day.

Shoddy Soldering Joints

Testing of FPV monitors usually involve a great deal of plugging and unplugging of power cables.

Such actions usually wear out components faster than expected, thus exposing weak points. One such weak point was discovered on the XT60 power connector of the FPV monitor which we took from the seniors:


Notice how the solder joint came off cleanly off the connector. This implies that whoever did the soldering for this was not very experienced. The temperature was hot enough for the solder to soak into the wire, but not hot enough for it to adhere to the XT60 connector. What’s more, since this fault was hidden under a layer of heatshrink, it would be impossible to spot until it decides to give way (which thankfully, happened in the lab and not while we’re flying)!

I proceeded to resolder the connector and all has been well ever since.

FPV Camera Tests

Though not critical to the success of our project, one of the functions we were looking to incorporate was the ability to have a live first person video (FPV) view of the airplane.

To achieve this, we require 4 main components:

  1. Camera (airside)
  2. Video Transmitter (airside)
  3. Video receiver (landside)
  4. Monitor (landside)

Note: The term airside implies that components labelled as such will be on the plane in the air while those marked as landside will remain on the ground at all times.

After doing some research and banking on our previous RC knowledge, we came up with the following list of items to buy from Taobao:

Camera: TOP RC Spotter v2 5.8GHz VTx + Camera

Our camera of choice!

Weighing just 9g, this camera is perfect for a plane with little cargo space like our Skysurfer.

To us, the main selling point was the fact that it was an integrated system: a camera and video transmitter with antenna all in one unit!

Besides saving space, this also means that the wiring job we have to do in order to get the live video feed working is reduced to just providing power to the unit (no need to worry about operating voltage differences between transmitter and camera and figuring out how to manage the rat’s nest of wires between the two aforementioned components)

We opted for the version with the cloverleaf antenna(that mushroom thing sticking out in the picture above) to reduce the likelihood of multipath interference.

Video Transmitter: ….??

As mentioned above, the video transmitter is integrated with the camera, so one less thing to worry about. Next.

Video Receiver: Eachine TS832

Our video receiver of choice

There was no specific reason as to why we chose this model over others, other than the fact that it just works.

Anyway, shortly I began my first tests with the camera, I started wishing that I had gotten a receiver with more frills. More on that later…

Monitor: Taken from MnT Lab

We did not buy a monitor off Taobao as during our first few visits to the lab, we realised that previous batches of PS9888 students bought a handful of monitors, together with spares that were never opened. So in order to save some money, we opted to use those hand-me-downs instead.

The requirement here was simple: all we needed was a monitor that will not display a blue screen (but rather static snow) on signal loss. This is because monitors that blue screen cut out completely when video signal dips below a certain level. As the likelihood of this happening when flying at distance is high, we need a screen that shows snow instead as these will still display a partial picture, giving us a fighting chance at flying our precious model back to safety.

Blue screen bad!

Snow good!

Functionality Test…

After plugging everything in, I realised that there was one simple(but rather serious) problem: I had no idea what channel my glorious video signal was being beamed on! There are tens of channels on the 5.8GHz spectrum so it was quite unrealistic and impractical to cycle through them one by one. It’s quite unfortunate that the RC832 unit we bought did not have auto scanning capabilities.

Seniors to the rescue!

Until I walked to the area behind the MnT lab and noticed sitting in this box this receiver:

“Auto Scan” 

Wasting no time, I set it up immediately and in no time, it automatically tuned to the correct channel, and was even kind enough to tell me what channel it was on!

Press the CH and FR buttons simultaneously and hey presto! Auto scan initialises!

Knowing the exact channel of the FPV transmitter, I could now tune our RC832 using the lookup table provided by the manufacturer.

Everything works but…

Knowing that everything worked was a  good sign. However, the lack of an auto scanning function mean that we had to use the Quanum receiver bought by our seniors. However, another problem ensued: the FPV camera/transmitter we purchased came only with a cloverleaf antenna soldered on, whereas the Quanum Receiver only came with inferior rubber ducky antennas. It’s not ideal mixing both types of antennas as that would reduce our video link range significantly.

FPV Camera with antenna soldered on

Although we bought extra cloverleaf antennas, we intended for them to be used with the RC832 only – which used RP-SMA connectors. The Quanum receiver uses SMA connectors. Bummer!

SMA on the seniors’ receiver

RP-SMA on the receiver we bought

Although leaving everything on one channel and not touching it afterwards would be the ideal scenario, this is unrealistic as we would be doing weekend flying and Old Holland Road – one of Singapore’s few designated drone flying zones – meaning that the area will be jam packed with other hobbyists doing FPV flying. It is quite likely that we will have to change frequencies in order to avoid interference (and crashing as a result)

With that, we figured that the best compromise to bring both receivers: the Quanum to verify the channel that the camera is on, and then tune to that frequency on the RC832.

First Flight

As Kanesh had deemed me and Isaac competent enough to fly the plane after going through a simulator test, it was now time to go out to the field for actual flights! Together with the delivery drone group, we met up with Kanesh at the Old Holland Road flying field on a lovely sunday morning

From left: Justin, Kanesh, Isaac and Kae

I was really nervous and my hands were trembling when the plane was launched by my groupmate. Although I had prior experience flying quadcopters as a hobby in my polytechnic days, fixed wing aircraft was a different ball game altogether. My reaction had to be many times faster as the aircraft has to be constantly in forward flight in order to stay airborne – unlike quadcopters which can hover. What’s more, flying circles meant that there are times when the plane’s nose will be facing me directly: meaning that the alieron inputs are essentially inverted!

Crashing in real life also meant a lot more downtime fixing the aircraft than crashing in the simulator.

Sure enough, the first few flights almost ended up in disaster as I was not used to controlling the airplane and nearly flew into one of my groupmates. I struggled to control the plane as it was pitching up and down wildly.

Something that exacerbated my bad flying was that I did not quite know how to trim the aircraft while in flight, because doing so would require me to take my thumbs off the control stick and move the trim switches, which was something I was not confident of doing. Alas, the plane few nonetheless and I was quite happy that I managed to learn some flying.

This session lasted quite a short while as the weather took a turn for the worse and it started to rain for the rest of the day, and this concludes the maiden flight of our group’s Skysurfer.

Bad Chinese Quality Control Strikes Again!

Finally the time came to transport our two Skysurfers to NTU and have them assembled. We opened the box excitedly like children opening Christmas presents. This excitement quickly turned into dismay when I realised that the dents in the retail box extended into the airplane foam, causing major deformation. To add insult to injury, the damage did not just occur in obscure, unimportant areas; there was major damage to the critical areas of the airframe also! Bummer!

Damage to the wing’s leading edge

 

Wing deformed

 

More damage – even the aileron was not spared

Fortunately, we bought two airframes so the second one was less damaged and in a more flyable condition. Hence, we chose to assemble that first.

However all was not lost, upon inspection by Kanesh, he determined that the faulty airframe could still be salvaged by flattening out the deformed parts with some weights.

Professor Google also recommended soaking the foam in hot (preferably boiling) water to have it expand. Problem was, the airplane was larger than any pot we could find. Thus, we had to settle for the second best option of pouring boiled water over the foam and then bend it back into its intended shape.

Found a kettle in the MnT lab…

And so began the painstaking work of letting the hot water soak into the foam and then slowly bending it back into its original shape, then putting a really heavy weight on it

Using one of the many discarded power supplies in the MnT lab as a weight to crush the foam back into shape

After a few hours of work, success! The wings are now back in an airworthy condition!

[TODO: add photos of wings after repairs]

Oversized Shipping Woes

It has been about 3 days since plan B (which involved us buying the airframe from Taobao) was activated.

As Cainiao’s forwarding warehouse was in Dongguan while the Skysurfer was dispatched from Wenzhou, we expected shipping to take some time due to the huge distance. We were thus pleasantly surprised at how the package consisting of two aeroplanes made it halfway across the country in half a day.

Wow!

Mad respect to Yuantong Express for the speedy delivery!

However, we were extremely dismayed to learn that our package had exceeded the maximum permissible dimensions for ordinary air shipping! What a bummer!

Love letter from Dylan from Zhongtong Express

Translation courtesy of Professor Google:

Hello, this is Zhongtong Taobao Collection Warehouse.
Please read the following carefully:

Your parcel (waybill number: YT4661635916747) cannot be consolidated because it exceeds the official Taobao shipping size regulations.
You can choose to return the package by express or transfer this package offline, and use Zhongtong Container Lines to continue the transshipment, and you need to pay the overseas freight of this package.

Air freight: The freight is RMB [396] and the time limit is 7-10 working days;
Shipping: The freight is RMB [137], and the time limit is 17-20 working days;

If you need to continue the transfer, please contact WeChat customer service WeChat account 16573409665
Official size regulations: The length of one side (length/width/height) should not exceed 80CM, and the sum of three sides (length + width + height) should not exceed 150CM.

If the package is not processed within 36 hours, it will be returned. If you have any questions, you can contact WeChat customer service: 16573940965 or contact Zhongtong Container Lines online customer service
Remarks: If there is no reply to this WhatsAPP, please contact WeChat customer service 16573940965
Remarks: Because WhataAPP is unstable, it may cause inconvenience to you. Please understand

Note: You can’t pay here, you can pay at Taobao shop in WeChat customer service
Remarks: If there is no WeChat, please contact the seller to let the seller contact the customer service of the warehouse. Thank you for your cooperation

If the WeChat customer service does not reply in time, please wait patiently, thank you, wish you a happy life

¥396 for air shipping! That’s around S$80! Outrageous! But oh well…we were working against time and would rather pay for faster shipping. So after explaining our predicament to Dr Ho, he allowed us to opt for the more expensive but faster air shipping. Hooray! After spending some time negotiating with Dylan on WeChat, we managed to make payment for oversized shipping. Here’s to hoping that it will arrive as soon as possible…

Behold, our premium shipping😢

 

Chinese Rescue Approved!

It as been a couple of days since unavailability of parts on HobbyKing halted progress on our drone. Though the possibility of obtaining the items we need on Taobao was always lurking in the corner, we were reluctant to do due to different people telling us different things regarding claiming from NTU. (Tony said that when he attempted to do so a while back his claim was rejected, whereas Dr Ho vaguely remembered that groups in previous years had successfully claimed for purchases on Taobao)

We also made our trailblazer order consisting of small, inexpensive items from Taobao to try our luck claiming. Should that go through, the million dollar question of whether or not we can claim from Taobao would be solved. Meanwhile, we also emailed Ms J to ask about claiming of items on non-English websites.

Big Hurrah!

Around a day after sending the email, two events happened in quick succession: our groupmate was summoned to a meeting regarding discrepancies in deducted amount between his bank statement and the receipt issued by Taobao. This was enough evidence to show show that contrary to what Tony said, we indeed could place our orders off Taobao!

Not long after, Ms J also replied to our email query:

Hurrah! We're through!

Taobao Approved!

Now comes the mad scramble to get our parts ordered and delivered as soon as possible!

Aircraft Parts Purchase: Attempt 1

Parts Approval: Attempt 1

Banking on our past experience with remote controlled aircraft, we came up with a parts list containing the following:

Our first attempt at going to Kanesh for approval

This was sent to Kanesh (a senior who is now running his own show and is assigned our mentor) to review.

Parts Approval: Attempt 1 Results

After around 3 days, Kanesh came back with the verdict. Overall, he was alright with the parts just that he strongly recommended that we use the Turnigy 9x, as there are sufficient online resources (manuals/videos) for setup/calibration/troubleshooting. Acceding to this request, we altered the parts list accordingly:

Second run after Kanesh's recommendations

Roadblock! $$$ Concerns!

After gleefully adding our items to the Hobbyking cart, we we going to checkout, eagerly expecting shipping to be cheap yet fast. Little did we expect to be greeted by a three figure shipping amount!

Rude surprise!

We were in for a rude surprise upon checkout!

Alas, we were told by Kanesh to hold our order; he will try to purchase the items for us using his account banking on the hope that his HobbyKing VIP status might grant him a substantial discount.

Just like that, our progress on building the drone has grinded to a halt: grand plans of spending the next week having bonding time in the lab building and flying the Bixler were shelved.